CBS Columbia Broadcasting System

A reality game on desert islands.

3/4 (Good).

There are plenty of likable people, very few jerks, and every single player is playing hard. They're not particularly great players, but they at least know what they're doing.

A reality game on desert islands.

1.5/4 (Meh).

Two vaguely competent players dominate the entire game, seemingly by accident, making for one of the most boring seasons ever. Other players acknowledge that they're not playing to win, and ultimately don't seem to care.

A reality game on desert islands.

2/4 (Indifferent).

The producers continue to undermine the game with b.s. "twists" that randomly kick people out without giving them a chance to strategize. Not that it mattered much with this particular group of players. But it doesn't seem likely that they'll be letting people play the game any time soon.

A reality game on desert islands.

2.5/4 (Okay).

Some great players play at their worst. Some entertaining players are edited at their worst. Unpredictable idol/advantage shenanigans interfere with strategy. And they don't let the audience know that the eventual winner knew what they were doing until the very end. This is a season of being excited to see what happens next, but never getting the satisfaction.