In actuality, I would give this book 3 and half stars. The last three or four chapters that made up the epilogue of the main character's story felt tacked on as though the reader wouldn't be able to make the logical leap of what would happen next in Faith/Dylan's life.

Dylan becomes ostracized at her school after a humiliating sext goes viral, and her workaholic parents can't really be bothered with their daughter. With no social life or friends, Dylan finds solace in the internet world of fundamentalist Christian girls. Creating a fundamentalist Christian alter ego known as Faith, Dylan becomes best friends with Abigail--the queen bee of the homeschooled Christian Girl blog set. She worms her way into spending two weeks with Abigail's family and learns some valuable lessons about herself while offering Abigail and her older brother insight's about themselves.

I give it to the author for trying to present Abigail's strict Christian lifestyle with fairness and without mockery. She did a good job of showing both the upsides and downsides of the girls' polar opposite lives. I did think she was a little heavy handed in her feminist message. I don't think she made it clear enough that a woman can be feminist and still enjoy cooking and taking care of a family. ( )

Sexting is something that has gotten a lot of media coverage lately — young girls taking and sending nude photos to their boyfriends; this often backfires when the couple breaks up, the photos are distributed, and charges are brought about regarding distribution of child pornography. But although that is the catalyst for this novel, it is not the central theme. Dylan is one of those girls — swept off her feet by the bad boy (despite warnings of her friends), and then tossed aside in a dramatic clash culminating in a smashed windshield and a flurry of picture texts. While she attempts to recuperate from the social ostracizing that occurs, Dylan finds herself reading the blog of a homeschooled fundamentalist Christian girl named Abigail, and becomes fascinated by her life, so very different from her own. And soon Dylan is making her own blog in an attempt to connect with Abigail and other girls like her.

I have to admit that I grew up with some girls like this. My parents did homeschool me, and my mother tried hard to make us fit into the good homeschooled Christian girl model (ala Elisabeth Elliot), although we were too Chinese to ever be the perfect fundamentalist girls. So I know all too well the world that the curious Dylan describes, right down to the “Christian girlhood” blogs that she reads, first with astonishment and a little scorn; I had friends who dabbled in writing similar newsletters, though these were actual mailed newsletters — no World Wide Web for them! I appreciate that in this story, Dylan’s experience with this foreign family and their odd lifestyle causes her to become closer to her own family and friends, creating an appreciation that she did not have before. That Dylan realizes she cannot force Abigail to accept her help in breaking away from the unhealthy aspects of the lifestyle is also very true to life. The author seems to do a good job at portraying Dylan’s attempts to understand and respect the lifestyle choices made by the fundamentalists while still disagreeing with some of their beliefs; however, upon reading Bloss’s blog, it is evident that she is adamantly anti-fundamentalist, calling her discoveries “sheer mind-boggling terror.” And while I too have issues with fundamentalism, for many of the same reasons that Dylan does in this novel, the author’s attitude of outright condemnation and disgust does not seem like the most appropriate way to bridge the gap to women who are emerging from this lifestyle, nor would it give teens much sympathy for someone recently emancipated from such a lifestyle. ( )

A very interesting novel about the Internet and blogs and how easy it is to become someone you're not. The first half of the book is solid but the second half wavers - almost as if the author didn't really know how to get her protagonist out of the situation. I also didn't like the ending very much - too neat and clean on one hand and yet too many threads left hanging. ( )

She’s “That Girl” who let a guy get between her and her best friends. Ostracized after her angry outburst following a sexting message gone public with said guy, Dylan becomes obsessed with the blogs of fundamentalist Christian homeschooled girls. She starts her own blog called Faith’s Surrender to His Bountiful Glory posing as a rural Wisconsin fundamentalist homeschooler. As Faith, she gets herself an invitation to visit Abigail, a devout and popular blogger on the circuit. Can Faith pull off the deception she’s created or will the truth come out? School Library Journal writes that “though this is Dylan's story, Bloss portrays all parties with a sympathetic eye, showing the strengths and weaknesses of both lifestyles and perspectives.”-SJ Cournoyer

(Miss) Dylan is caught in a sexting scandal (spurned boyfriend...compromising pix) and subsequently shunned by her classmates. In her loneliness, she discovers an online community of home-schooled conservative Christians, where is both intrigued and comforted by their traditional values. She soon adopts an alter ego, "Faith," and begins her own blog. She is befriended by Abigail and the subterfuge accelerates when Dylan travels to So. Illinois to spend time with Abigail. The summer opens Dylan's eyes to an alternative view of the world, tests the limits of honesty (in the end she confesses her true identity to Abigail), introduces a boy crush (the brooding Asher) and leaves Dylan in a better place than where she started. Author Bloss does a good job of bringing various threads together to a satisfying resolution. She treats the conservative Christian community with dignity while exposing some of its constraints. The boyfriend subplot is a bit less convincing but will hook teen girls. Best of all: Dylan shows real character growth. ( )