This is the third book in the supernatural sisters, and we finally get to see the nerdy book, loving youngest sister, who is a professor get together with the guardian angel. We know she’s a professor over at Harvard and she really wants to study having apprenticeships between human and supernatural societies to create a better understanding of both societies. However, things aren’t going so well, and she needs to move into a new apartment. Our guardian angel gives her space in his place. The problem is everybody knows these two have a hots for each other and just can’t talk about it. And of course, moving in together means they become involved. The downside is that Box is given Olive as an official duty to guard. He tries to tell his boss we’ve been friends we live together, but they’re like do this or you’re fired. You see Olive has decided she’s going to do 10 things that are scary. She assigned her students this project but thinks if I’m going to give it to them why don’t I do it myself. This book, of course involves sex, singing, doing crazy unexpected things, and things that scare you. This book is just like the others. It’s cozy, it’s a little spicy, maybe a little more than spicy… they get into piercings. But it is fun. I really like this series and I hope it isn’t over because I really want the book about their succubus friend. ( )

Olive & Bax, eek! They are so cute together and I love how they both came to the same realization at the same time. On a side note, the idea of a magic ink for tattoos that guarantees your tattoo will last forever and never fade is so cool and makes me wish it was a reality. I don't know if there will be further books in this series but if there are, I will read them.

Zura Johnson did a great job narrating this novel and I will definitely look for more books narrated by Zura in the future. ( )

Not Your Crush’s Cauldron by April Asher
Supernatural Singles series #3. Witchy paranormal romance. Can be read as a standalone but better as part of the series of the three sisters.
Olive Maxwell prefers teaching about the supernatural world rather than taking part in it. She gets a bit of a wake up call career wise, and after assigning her college students a project designed to nudge them out of their comfort zones, she decides to take her own assignment to heart and make changes in her own life. First on the list of changes is moving in with Baxter Donovan, a long-time crush, friend, and tattooed, motorcycle-riding guardian Angel.
Bax Donovan believes his charges should have free will, so his records aren’t all top marks. His newest assignment is Olive, who is usually low-risk. He’s more than willing to spend time helping her expand her boundaries and try new things. Bax needs to remember to keep his hands to himself while they are both trying new things. He has his own rules of Conduct to follow even though it’s going to be one of the hardest things he’s ever done.

Amusing, sexy, and empowering. A reminder to get out and try your own new things.
Bax and Olive have some serious issues but by putting the worry aside, living and loving, and trying new things, they feel better able to deal with obstacles.
Olive’s list is crazy! I’m not going to be an acrobatic silks performer, nor am I going anywhere near the rest of her list. But a little fantasy love play may be doable. Inspiring, if only… ( )

I voluntarily agreed to read and honestly review this book.
Another fun Supernatural Singles story from April Asher! This time we get to read about Witch-Triplet Olive Maxwell. And the male MC, Baxter Donovan, is a Guardian Angel. I laughed and giggled my way through this book. And, I may have growled a little when reading the parts involving Mikael Donovan, Bax’s father. All in all, this was a great, and fun, read for those moments when I needed a break from Real Life. ( )

Not Your Crush's Cauldron is the third book in the Supernatural Singles series by April Asher.

A paranormal romance, Olive is the youngest of the Maxwell triplet witches, with a crush on long-time friend and now roommate Baxter Donovan. Olive is known for being predictable and boring, but she recently assigned her students a Dare I Docket to get them out of their comfort zones, and she's determined to create her own. Bax has been part of the Maxwell friend group for years, and when Olive needed somewhere to stay, he offered his spare room to her. Unbeknownst to Olive, Bax has been assigned as her Guardian Angel because of her risky Dare I Docket, and when they start spending all their time together, the feelings they both have been having come to the forefront, and spice ensues.

Olive is a relatable character, stuck in her everyday life, staying on the safe side of life. Other than her being a witch, she's a normal single woman dealing with family and work. Her sisters are always there for her, no matter what she might need. Bax is a complicated guy, having feelings for Olive and being unable to tell her due to the Guardian Angel Rules. He doesn't like being a Guardian Angel, but doesn't have a choice due to family obligations. All of the characters are well-developed with their own distinct personalities.

All in all, a spicy friends to lovers romance with some magic thrown in. I haven't read the first two books, but I assume they were about Violet and Rose finding their true loves. I was a little uncertain how Olive didn't know that Bax had feelings for her when, as soon as he appeared, he was winking and flirting with her, but I guess she had to be naive for a book to be written. If you enjoy a little witchy-ness and friends to lovers, then this series would be a good choice.

Thank you to @NetGalley and @StMartinsPress for a digital copy for review consideration. All opinions are honest and my own. ( )