Autoren-Bilder
12 Werke 71 Mitglieder 3 Rezensionen

Über den Autor

Andrew Levine is the author of many books and articles most recently Political Keywords, The American Ideology, and A Future for Marxism? He was, for many years, professor of philosophy at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and, more recently, research professor in philosophy at the University of mehr anzeigen Maryland-College Park. He is currently a senior scholar at the Institute for Policy Studies, Washington, DC. weniger anzeigen

Werke von Andrew Levine

Getagged

Wissenswertes

Geschlecht
male

Mitglieder

Rezensionen

Una storia complessa raccontata a due voci, prima prova di un giovane scrittore. Nel complesso il giudizio è positivo anche se la trama risulta alla fine sforzata e un in parte anche piuttosto incongruente e i personaggi secondari troppo poco caratterizzati. Lo stile risulta comunque avvincente e ci si appassiona alla storia. Molto promettente, quattro stelle proprio perchè è il suo primo libro.
 
Gekennzeichnet
Raffaella10 | Jan 28, 2023 |
Andrew Levine not only supports what scholars of religion call the "secularization hypothesis," according to which religions are in a gradual and global state of social decline, but he also subscribes to what one might term a secularization agenda: approving that decline and hoping that it proceeds swiftly. In this brief volume, he traces a line of investigation through a set of nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Continental thinkers: Feuerbach, Durkheim, Nietzsche, and Freud. The question at issue for these four presumes the falsehood of conventional religion, and seeks to understand why it persists.

Although I was in many respects entertained by and sympathetic to the treatment of the nineteenth-century figures, there was little new to me here. The one point in this book where I actually felt I was getting some fresh education was in Levine's history of the emergence of liberal Judaism (175-180). This passage was set within a more general chapter on "The Liberal Turn" that provides accounts of liberalizing developments in Protestantism, Judaism, Catholicism, and Islam.

The focus is exclusively on the European history of religion, along with its radiation to colonial and post-colonial environments. The book has nothing useful to say about Confucianism, Taoism, Buddhism, Hinduism, or other religions outside of the "Abrahamic" traditions. At several points it offers and uses an explanation of Deism that seems to make theism a specialization of the more general Deist principles (20, 130). While this might be a way of characterizing their relationship in the logical space of theology (with credit to Ioan Culianu for that paradigm), it is misleading in terms of their genealogy and intellectual history. The Deist creed--to which hardly anyone any longer subscribes as such--was an early effort at liberalizing Western religion, a fact which is obscured in this book where it ought to be highlighted.

Categorically hostile to religion, Levine is willing to dismiss all mystical experience as pathology. In this, I think he errs. For example, he takes drug-based instances of religious ecstasy as demonstrating that mystical raptures generally have "no cognitive import" (120). The fact (supported by drug evidence) is that mystical experience is not theologically probative. However, the similarities and interplay between religious and psychopharmaceutical phenomena are worth more serious consideration. Ethnobotanical theories of religious origins are not trivial, and lie well beyond the Feuerbachian and Freudian concepts of god-formation.

The moral of Levine's story is that full secularization--the extinction of religion--is needed and inevitable, but may not come soon enough. The engaging and somewhat ironic dimension of his analysis is that the liberalized religious communities will be the hardest to break of their delusions, weak tea though they may be. Liberalism may serve as a vaccine against the godlessness needed to achieve human freedom.
… (mehr)
3 abstimmen
Gekennzeichnet
paradoxosalpha | May 4, 2018 |
Reading Rousseau back INTO Kant in an interesting and illuminating way
 
Gekennzeichnet
vegetarian | Dec 15, 2011 |

Statistikseite

Werke
12
Mitglieder
71
Beliebtheit
#245,552
Bewertung
4.0
Rezensionen
3
ISBNs
25

Diagramme & Grafiken