Permanent Daylight Savings Time
ForumPro and Con
Melde dich bei LibraryThing an, um Nachrichten zu schreiben.
1Molly3028
https://www.washingtonian.com/2022/03/15/the-us-tried-permanent-daylight-saving-...
WRITTEN BY ANDREW BEAUJON
The US Tried Permanent Daylight Saving Time in the ’70s. People Hated It
.....Congress had voted on December 14, 1973, to put the US on daylight saving time for two years. President Nixon signed the bill the next day. The US had gone to permanent daylight saving time before, during World War II. Then, too, the measure was enacted to save fuel. Permanent DST wasn’t close to the wackiest idea about time floating around—Paul Mullinax, a geographer who worked at the Pentagon, came up with the idea of putting the continental US on a single time zone. “USA Time” would apply from Bangor to Barstow, eliminate jet lag, and standardize TV schedules. His idea even got traction in Congress, via a bill from US Representative Patsy Mink of Hawaii. “The human being is a very adaptive animal,” he said. “There is no reason we have to be a slave to the sun.”
And yet the early-morning darkness quickly proved dangerous for children: A 6-year-old Alexandria girl was struck by a car on her way to Polk Elementary School on January 7; the accident broke her leg. Two Prince George’s County students were hurt in February. In the weeks after the change, eight Florida kids were killed in traffic accidents. Florida’s governor, Reubin Askew, asked for Congress to repeal the measure. “It’s time to recognize that we may well have made a mistake,” US Senator Dick Clark of Iowa said during a speech in Congress on January 28, 1974. In the Washington area, some schools delayed their start times until the sun caught up with the clock.
The factual picture was a bit more complicated. The National Safety Council reported in February that pre-sunrise fatalities had risen to 20 from 18 the year before. In July, Roger Sant, then an assistant administrator-designate for the Federal Energy Administration, wrote a letter to the Post that noted a 1 percent energy saving achieved by going to DST equated to 20,000-30,000 tons of coal not being burned each day. Further, he wrote, accidents had fallen in the afternoons.
By August, though, as the Watergate scandal caused the Nixon administration to crumble, the country was ready to move on from its clock experiments. While 79 percent of Americans approved of the change in December 1973, approval had dropped to 42 percent three months later, the New York Times reported. Seven days after President Nixon resigned, US Senator Bob Dole of Kansas introduced an amendment in August that would end the DST experiment. It passed. A similar bill passed the House. In late September, the full Congress passed a bill that would restore standard time on October 27. President Ford signed it on October 5. Energy savings, a House panel noted, “must be balanced against a majority of the public’s distaste for the observance of Daylight Saving Time.”
***
I vote NO ~ the last thing we need is longer, dark, depressing winter mornings!
WRITTEN BY ANDREW BEAUJON
The US Tried Permanent Daylight Saving Time in the ’70s. People Hated It
.....Congress had voted on December 14, 1973, to put the US on daylight saving time for two years. President Nixon signed the bill the next day. The US had gone to permanent daylight saving time before, during World War II. Then, too, the measure was enacted to save fuel. Permanent DST wasn’t close to the wackiest idea about time floating around—Paul Mullinax, a geographer who worked at the Pentagon, came up with the idea of putting the continental US on a single time zone. “USA Time” would apply from Bangor to Barstow, eliminate jet lag, and standardize TV schedules. His idea even got traction in Congress, via a bill from US Representative Patsy Mink of Hawaii. “The human being is a very adaptive animal,” he said. “There is no reason we have to be a slave to the sun.”
And yet the early-morning darkness quickly proved dangerous for children: A 6-year-old Alexandria girl was struck by a car on her way to Polk Elementary School on January 7; the accident broke her leg. Two Prince George’s County students were hurt in February. In the weeks after the change, eight Florida kids were killed in traffic accidents. Florida’s governor, Reubin Askew, asked for Congress to repeal the measure. “It’s time to recognize that we may well have made a mistake,” US Senator Dick Clark of Iowa said during a speech in Congress on January 28, 1974. In the Washington area, some schools delayed their start times until the sun caught up with the clock.
The factual picture was a bit more complicated. The National Safety Council reported in February that pre-sunrise fatalities had risen to 20 from 18 the year before. In July, Roger Sant, then an assistant administrator-designate for the Federal Energy Administration, wrote a letter to the Post that noted a 1 percent energy saving achieved by going to DST equated to 20,000-30,000 tons of coal not being burned each day. Further, he wrote, accidents had fallen in the afternoons.
By August, though, as the Watergate scandal caused the Nixon administration to crumble, the country was ready to move on from its clock experiments. While 79 percent of Americans approved of the change in December 1973, approval had dropped to 42 percent three months later, the New York Times reported. Seven days after President Nixon resigned, US Senator Bob Dole of Kansas introduced an amendment in August that would end the DST experiment. It passed. A similar bill passed the House. In late September, the full Congress passed a bill that would restore standard time on October 27. President Ford signed it on October 5. Energy savings, a House panel noted, “must be balanced against a majority of the public’s distaste for the observance of Daylight Saving Time.”
***
I vote NO ~ the last thing we need is longer, dark, depressing winter mornings!
2Limelite
It won't be long before permanent DST is overturned. Little Marco Rubio is from South FL; I lived in Miami over 30 years; subtropical latitudes don't experience the day length/shortness according to seasons like most of the country which lies in higher latitudes. One winter of sending their children to school in the winter dark will elicit howls of protest from families who live north of the FL panhandle.
The sane thing to do is to banish DST permanently. Let businesses and individuals start their work day an hour earlier, if they want -- "Sun time." The workplace has changed and can accommodate staggered work schedules since more and more employees work from home. That new way to work out-of-office proved successful for more than two years. Adjusting to staggered work schedules for employees who go to a workplace will be even simpler.
Biologically, our species, like every other, adapts to solar rhythms naturally. It doesn't adapt to artificial delimiters like clocks. For obvious practical reasons. Why mandate the impractical solution to what is really a non-problem in the first place?
End the DST fiction.
The sane thing to do is to banish DST permanently. Let businesses and individuals start their work day an hour earlier, if they want -- "Sun time." The workplace has changed and can accommodate staggered work schedules since more and more employees work from home. That new way to work out-of-office proved successful for more than two years. Adjusting to staggered work schedules for employees who go to a workplace will be even simpler.
Biologically, our species, like every other, adapts to solar rhythms naturally. It doesn't adapt to artificial delimiters like clocks. For obvious practical reasons. Why mandate the impractical solution to what is really a non-problem in the first place?
End the DST fiction.
3ljbryant
>2 Limelite: Personally, I don't care WHICH direction we go with the clocks. Permanent DST, or banishing DST entirely. Either way works just fine for me -- but switching off and on is ridiculous, and kills people (https://www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/news/20211105/harmful-effects-of-daylight-savings#:~:text=A%202019%20report%20found%20a,States%20during%20daylight%20saving%20time.)
That's a lot worse than the additional 2 fatalities mentioned in >1 Molly3028:.
That's a lot worse than the additional 2 fatalities mentioned in >1 Molly3028:.
