9/10 (excellent): An excellent commentary on Hosea, head and shoulders above anything else I read. I highly recommend it to those who are preaching through this minor prophet. It's scholarly, without being overly technical or critical, and has a rare blend of common-sense interpretation with genuine insight. ( )

A great commentary. I especially liked his sidenotes that discussed theological and historical issues in the text. NICOT is probably my favorite commentary series after reading this book.