StartseiteGruppenForumMehrZeitgeist
Web-Site durchsuchen
Diese Seite verwendet Cookies für unsere Dienste, zur Verbesserung unserer Leistungen, für Analytik und (falls Sie nicht eingeloggt sind) für Werbung. Indem Sie LibraryThing nutzen, erklären Sie dass Sie unsere Nutzungsbedingungen und Datenschutzrichtlinie gelesen und verstanden haben. Die Nutzung unserer Webseite und Dienste unterliegt diesen Richtlinien und Geschäftsbedingungen.
Hide this

Ergebnisse von Google Books

Auf ein Miniaturbild klicken, um zu Google Books zu gelangen.

The Wrong War: Grit, Strategy, and the Way…
Lädt ...

The Wrong War: Grit, Strategy, and the Way Out of Afghanistan (2011. Auflage)

von Bing West

MitgliederRezensionenBeliebtheitDurchschnittliche BewertungDiskussionen
932233,379 (3.71)3
From one of America's most renowned war correspondents comes the definitive account of the Afghanistan war, a damning policy assessment, and a compelling and controversial way forward.
Mitglied:BookBully
Titel:The Wrong War: Grit, Strategy, and the Way Out of Afghanistan
Autoren:Bing West
Info:Random House (2011), Hardcover, 336 pages
Sammlungen:Personal Library
Bewertung:
Tags:Keine

Werk-Details

The Wrong War: Grit, Strategy, and the Way Out of Afghanistan von Bing West

Keine
Lädt ...

Melde dich bei LibraryThing an um herauszufinden, ob du dieses Buch mögen würdest.

A really comprehensive analysis of the US involvement in Afghanistan as of 2009/2010, Mr. West has spent plenty of time with the troops on the frontline and he provides good points, based on experience, to sustain his arguments as well as a few amusing vignettes that are welcome in the middle of so many shots, explosions and uncooperative local tribesmen.

Sadly, as I thought this was going to be one of the best books on the war that I'd read, the conclusions to what Mr. West arrives, his tenets for COIN if you want, are repeated time and time again, without adding much extra detail to them. ( )
  emed0s | May 16, 2012 |
Crazy as it sounds, the title does not mean that the war in Afghanistan is wrong but that, according to the author, it is fought in the wrong way. In the author's opinion the right way to fight that war is to take all gloves off: Boer type concentration camps, free-fire zones, torture - basically everything that never worked should be applied to "win" that war. Winning in West's opinion means installing a pro-USA dictator. This book reveals an ugly and crazy mindset that projects the frustration of losing a war into a modern "Dolchstoßlegende". West's hatred for Islamists barely exceeds his contempt and hatred for Europeans and liberals. In order to kill some more Muslims, West is willing to jettison most human rights. His trauma of Vietnam is strong. Meet the sick mind of Colonel Kurtz. One strange opinion that seems to gain more and more hold is the idea that an act isn't a war crime if there are no surviving witnesses. The moral rot has not been contained yet.

To test the practicability of his ideas, I wish these analysts applied their prescriptions to the American War of Independence. Could Great Britain turn the tide of war if it had applied the measures proffered? A realistic assessment reveals that West's and other authors' recommendations would not be helpful at all. There were never enough boots on the ground, and even if they were they were more likely to trample on the natives' liberties than improve their lot. Counterinsurgency best practice recommends a 1:50 ratio of soldiers to occupied people. In Afghanistan, the ratio was/is 1:2000. The ratio of American policemen stands at 2.5:1000. Thus, for the bigger task of pacifying Afghanistan, one fifth of the police force ratio in the US is available. As long as the troop commitment remains at homoeopathic level, any expectation of success is unrealistic. Piled on this are mountains of lunatic decisions. Thus a teacher is only paid 70 USD, half of what a policeman receives, whose pay in turn is half of that of a soldier. The policemen are extremely unhappy with their meager salary and it is practically impossible to find teachers willing to work for such paltry pay. On the other hand, every army meal served costs the US taxpayer 28 USD. To balance the army's appetite, the US Congress just cut American children's food assistance. The way out of this wrong war is not to double down and sacrifice humanity but a fast exit. Staying in Afghanistan is not helping in any way. US political priorities are a mess.

If one is able to ignore the author's sick philosophy, the book contains two quite valuable accounts of the fighting in the North-East in the Korengal Valley (as told in Junger's War/Restrepo) and the failed COIN effort in the South in Helmand province (basically Vietnam all over again). The best part is the description of a firefight that illustrates the difference between forces present and active. On a patrol of 13 Marines, 60 Afghan soldiers and 20 Afghan policemen, supported by about 25 US soldiers and six snipers, the US soldiers cover the rear and are not allowed to join the fight. The Afghan soldiers and policemen also only pump the air full of lead. Most of the Marines are pinned to the ground. The only one actually fighting on the US side is Corporal Meyer, assisted by his interpreter. Achilles-like, he charges in, again and again, rescuing his buddies and firing at his enemies, switching vehicles when they become too damaged or his ammo runs out. While his testosterone warrior approach is unstoppable on the battlefield, he quickly runs afoul of the professional army off the battlefield and quits his military service. In a conventional war, Cpl Meyer would be a (short-lived) ace. In a war of occupation, Rambo antics constitute a danger.

In conclusion, the good reporting about the American military failures in North-East and South Afghanistan is marred by a truly sick frame of mind and unhelpful "lessons" that the US military hopefully will ignore. ( )
5 abstimmen jcbrunner | Aug 9, 2011 |
keine Rezensionen | Rezension hinzufügen
Du musst dich einloggen, um "Wissenswertes" zu bearbeiten.
Weitere Hilfe gibt es auf der "Wissenswertes"-Hilfe-Seite.
Gebräuchlichster Titel
Originaltitel
Alternative Titel
Ursprüngliches Erscheinungsdatum
Figuren/Charaktere
Wichtige Schauplätze
Wichtige Ereignisse
Zugehörige Filme
Preise und Auszeichnungen
Epigraph (Motto/Zitat)
Widmung
Erste Worte
Zitate
Letzte Worte
Hinweis zur Identitätsklärung
Verlagslektoren
Werbezitate von
Originalsprache
Anerkannter DDC/MDS
Anerkannter LCC

Literaturhinweise zu diesem Werk aus externen Quellen.

Wikipedia auf Englisch (2)

From one of America's most renowned war correspondents comes the definitive account of the Afghanistan war, a damning policy assessment, and a compelling and controversial way forward.

Keine Bibliotheksbeschreibungen gefunden.

Buchbeschreibung
Zusammenfassung in Haiku-Form

Beliebte Umschlagbilder

Gespeicherte Links

Bewertung

Durchschnitt: (3.71)
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3 4
3.5 3
4 3
4.5
5 2

Bist das du?

Werde ein LibraryThing-Autor.

 

Über uns | Kontakt/Impressum | LibraryThing.com | Datenschutz/Nutzungsbedingungen | Hilfe/FAQs | Blog | LT-Shop | APIs | TinyCat | Nachlassbibliotheken | Vorab-Rezensenten | Wissenswertes | 163,316,642 Bücher! | Menüleiste: Immer sichtbar