Zoey has had a crush on Evan since they first met in high school, but has never acted on those feelings. She has always felt she wasn't Evan's type and their friendship means too much to her to jeopardize. At a Halloween party, Zoey meets Griffin, something Evan isn't too happy about. Zoey and Griffin's budding relationship grows into something Zoey never thought she would find, that four letter word, love. When she is ready to marry Griffin, Evan decides to let his true feelings be known. Ultimately, Zoey has to decide, marry the one the currently loves, or be with the one she's always loved.