I listened to the audio version and this may have coloured my view of the story. Not much happens in this small, Australian country town so the locals are scandalised when two people go missing.
I found this a bit dreary and uninspiring and wasn’t much interested in the mystery. But what really gave this the two star rating was the poor editing of the narration. Really - no one says “post-HEW-muss-lee” (posthumously) and no one goes fishing for “breem.” ( )

Very good, well done small town characters and plot ( )

This was just the read I needed after a previous hard slog.
Goodwood is a small town in NSW. In 1991 the people of the town appear content. It is hard not to know everyone else's business, so there is much gossip but not really of a malicious nature. Seventeen year old Jean is our narrator. She lives with her Mum, Celia and enjoys a close relationship with her Nan. The local policeman is her Mum's cousin Mack. The town feels safe until a young woman, a year older than Jean, goes missing. The townsfolk become fearful. The event unheard of in the town's history. When a week later a popular local figure, the town's butcher goes missing while fishing, the gossip mill is fueled and anxiety is rife.
The book features an enjoyable mix of characters and the case of the missing two people is brought to a credible conclusion. I hadn't realised the book was crime fiction, so found this an added dimension to the story. The one thing I will say was that the setting felt universal rather than distinctly Australian. ( )

Story of a small Australian town with characters that hide secrets, slowly discovered after two people go missing. ( )

Small town living in 1990's Australia is big in GOODWOOD, which is interesting as this is a slow burning, confined, seemingly "small" story in the life of 17 year old Jean. She lives in Goodwood, a small town, near a bigger town, with her mother, near her grandparents, surrounded by people she knows, or is somehow related to, all of whom are known, related to somebody. It's the sort of town where you go to the bigger town to do the big shop, but the local town is where you get the essentials - and the gossip - and the support and understanding. There is so much that rings true about that time, and the reality of small town life that you can really believe / understand how it is that the disappearance of two people from such a small community has such a profound impact. Even more understandable is Jean's confusion and her way of processing not just the disappearances, but the fallout for everyone in the town. Suspicion and fear don't rub along well in a world with, as Jean's Nan puts it, "a high density of acquaintanceship".

Small is a poor description to use for this novel but it's a hard one to explain. It's small in that the location, the events, the impact is local and the ramifications don't seem to stretch much outside the community. It's not small in that those ramifications are pretty shattering for that small a community, but they are illustrated more in the day to day, than in grand psychological analysis. It's also a slow burner, languid, as the mystery behind these two disappearances is used to explore consequence and the impact of the unexpected. Jean's observations about the communities reactions, the slow twitch of discomfort that everyone is experiencing, and the different ways it manifests is beautifully executed. Dryly funny, observant and both young and old for her age, Jean's the perfect sort of character to carry the narrative here forward and a bit sideways at times. GOODWOOD is not really about the investigation of disappearance, it's about the fallout.

Jean's style is enhanced by a great supporting cast, with plenty of believable characters in their own right, many of whom are able to drop a truism into a conversation as effortlessly as they do a little gem of Australian-style wisdom. Jean's Nan made me laugh out loud on more than one occasion, as she let go lines that my own Grandmother would have happily and unflinchingly served up.

GOODWOOD came flagged as a crime fiction novel, and the thing I'm increasingly coming to admire in Australian Crime writing circles is how widely that genre definition is starting to spread. This isn't crime / investigation as mentioned above, but it's definitely possible crime / fallout and ramifications.

https://www.austcrimefiction.org/review/goodwood-holly-throsby ( )