"Dark Shadows Falling" is yet another example of a climber decrying the media for its coverage of mountaineering accidents, then writing a book and making money by offering opinions about the accident themselves. I always find this odd.

However, Joe Simpson certainly has something to say that's worth hearing. His own near-death experience, well documented in the excellent book "Touching the Void," gives him an interesting perspective. This book, which is part memoir and part essay on concerns about climbing ethics and the attitude of getting to the summit at any cost.

An interesting and thought provoking read. ( )

Joe Simpson writes beautifully and honestly. His passion for climbing is very clear from his books. ( )

An uncompromising look at the state of mountaineering, specifically on Everest. Simpson wrestles with environmental concerns and ethical and moral dilemas. However, he seems more disappointed than anything about the lengths people seem willing to go to in order to summit. ( )

Much soul searching as to the state of modern climbing and the state of mind of the people who undertake it, with special reference to larger commercial expeditions. ( )