53282

Having read the first novel in the quartet ("Savannah"), I couldn't wait to read the next one, but found myself with mixed feelings from the start. While the whole story of the Pulaski shipwreck - taken from actual events, as are many situations in Ms. Price's novels - was well written, as it didn't go heavy on melodrama and at the same time made you feel you were really there (I could swear I know what it's like to be floating in the middle of the ocean, sunburnt and thirsty, surrounded by wreckage and corpses), the rest of the novel was less than stellar, due to the self centered, spoiled leading lady, Natalie Browning, daughter of Mark Browning, leading man in the previous book.

I believe Ms. Price was trying to create a character to rival Scarlett O'Hara, but she didn't quite make it. Scarlett may have been willful, headstrong and self-centered, but she never came across as a childish brat, the way Natalie did. (Not to mention that Natalie's favorite expression of scorn, "Foot!", hardly compares to "Fiddle Dee Dee!") While both young women went through tragedy, Scarlett's experiences made her grow up fast, whereas Natalie just became more of a willful child.
Scarlett had to cope with her whole way of life being destroyed along with Atlanta, and had to start over with strength and determination. Her great weakness was her obsession with the wrong man.

Natalie, on the other hand, obsesses over the right one, and expects everyone else in her life to act as if nothing else mattered besides her love story with Burke Latimer. Given that they met under highly unusual circumstances (a shipwreck being far from the average social gathering) all her family wanted her to do was give things a little time, to be sure what she felt wasn't some sort of knight-in-shining-armor syndrome, especially since she was still a teenager. Princess Natalie acts as if they committed high treason! How dare they try to prevent her from marrying her true love right away! Too often, her parents chose to dance to whatever tune she played, because she considered it a betrayal if they didn't, and this was a very disappointing part of the novel, since in the first book, they were strong, independent characters, particularly Mark Browning, who - much to my chagrin - was now more a pathetic shadow of a man, who allowed himself to be dominated by his brat of a daughter.

Ditto everyone else, except the man of her dreams. Burke's the only one with a backbone that he won't let Natalie break. (One of the results of this is Natalie burning his house down, and him walking out of her life for quite some time. The fact that he comes back emphasizes this being a work of fiction. And even so, Rhett Butler walked away with an "I don't give a damn", too bad Mr. Latimer didn't follow suit.)

A very disappointing read after "Savannah", one that prevented me from reading the next two novels. I have a feeling I didn't miss much, especially if Natalie was still around. Many a time wished she had drowned at sea. ( )

Where I got the book: review copy provided by publisher. My feature article on the Savannah Quartet appears on the Historical Novel Society website.

This second novel of the Savannah Quartet begins with a disaster, so heavily foreshadowed pretty much from the beginning that I don’t feel I’m being spoilerish telling you about it. The melodrama quotient climbs to stratospheric levels as Natalie Browning struggles to survive and falls in love at the same time. Much of the rest of the novel is about Natalie pursuing the object of her somewhat obsessive love into the Georgia backcountry, giving Price a great reason to explore the settlement of inland Georgia and the history of some of its real-life inhabitants, not to mention the plight of the Cherokees who were being driven out of Georgia onto the Trail of Tears at the time.

I spent much of the book wanting to smack Natalie, who never, at any point in this series, seems to behave like a proper adult, but I still enjoyed it. There was tons of drama, and Price never missed an opportunity to exploit all the opportunities her overblown plot gave her. This is one of those books where you roll your eyes a lot but you still keep reading, and become fond of the characters despite their failings. ( )