Auf ein Miniaturbild klicken, um zu Google Books zu gelangen.
Lädt ... Baseball Between the Numbers : Why Everything You Know About the Game Is Wrong (2006)von The Baseball Prospectus Team of Experts, Jonah Keri (Herausgeber)
Keine Lädt ...
Melde dich bei LibraryThing an um herauszufinden, ob du dieses Buch mögen würdest. Keine aktuelle Diskussion zu diesem Buch. Many legitimate and some non-obvious observations are painstakingly established here. But, there is a rather significant caveat: This book almost seems designed for the purpose of making you better appreciate Bill James: it's badly written. Bill James should not just have been a figure to be acknowledged in the preface--his brevity and clarity should have served as a model for the Baseball Prospectus team. Instead we get interminable lead-ins to simple and already well-known concepts like park factor. Other themes are ironically obscured by the authors "too much is never enough" approach to evidence and graphic depictions thereof. The Baseball Prospectus team never establishes any kind of rapport with their readers. Where James makes you feel like he's engaging you in a bar-room conversation in baseball Valhalla, Baseball Prospectus makes you feel like a professor reading a rather interesting but unfortunately ham-handed term paper. I got stuck on the chapter about Leverage (I'll probably have to go back and read it again), but the rest of the book had some interesting observations... My favorites: * Players are better in their 'walk-year' of a contract * 5 year "rebuilding" plans rarely work * Branch Rickey's observation: "Luck is the residue of design" If you ever wanted to scratch the surface of advance statistical study of baseball, this is the first book I'd start with. Not a straight cover to cover book, but rather a grouping of essays about a variety of topics. They range from the humorous but thought provoking "What if Rickey Henderson had Pete Incavilia's legs?" to the argument inducing "Did Derek Jeter deserve the Gold Glove". Some essays can gloss over the eyeballs with the depth of statistical information, but the vast majority keep it interesting enough to rope in the more casual fan. Zeige 5 von 5 keine Rezensionen | Rezension hinzufügen
In the numbers-obsessed sport of baseball, statistics don't merely record what players, managers, and owners have done. Properly understood, they can tell us how the teams we root for could employ better strategies, put more effective players on the field, and win more games. The revolution in baseball statistics that began in the 1970s is a controversial subject that professionals and fans alike argue over without end. Despite this fundamental change in the way we watch and understand the sport, no one has written the book that reveals, across every area of strategy and management, how the best practitioners of statistical analysis in baseball-people like Bill James, Billy Beane, and Theo Epstein-think about numbers and the game. Baseball Between the Numbers is that book. In separate chapters covering every aspect of the game, from hitting, pitching, and fielding to roster construction and the scouting and drafting of players, the experts at Baseball Prospectus examine the subtle, hidden aspects of the game, bring them out into the open, and show us how our favorite teams could win more games. This is a book that every fan, every follower of sports radio, every fantasy player, every coach, and every player, at every level, can learn from and enjoy. Keine Bibliotheksbeschreibungen gefunden. |
Aktuelle DiskussionenKeineBeliebte Umschlagbilder
Google Books — Lädt ... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)796.357021The arts Recreational and performing arts Athletic and outdoor sports and games Ball sports Ball and stick sports Baseball MiscellanyKlassifikation der Library of Congress [LCC] (USA)BewertungDurchschnitt:
Bist das du?Werde ein LibraryThing-Autor. |
The BP crew shows the most direct Bill James influence of everyone doing baseball analysis in public, in that much of their work is built directly on James' work. They use different, and often more sophisticated, measures than was/is James' practice, but it's always pretty obvious that their work began with Bill. This is neither a strength nor a weakness; it's just the way they work. (One does wonder, though, why there's no similar congregation of writers influenced by Pete Palmer.)
The book is built around 27 questions (outs), organized into 9 chapters (innings)--questions like "Why are pitchers so unpredictable?" and "Is there such a thing as a quadruple-A player?" The 28th (extra innings) chapter is, unsurprisingly, about scouts and stats. The chapters usually have a single author, though there's some obvious cross-fertilization and two have co-authors. Each chapter explores the title question, and often related subjects, in some detail, testing hypotheses and discussing the results. The precise tools they've used are not usually directly displayed, but the authors show enough data that you can do a parallel analysis if you're so inclined. (Some of the tools are fully described in the Glossary or the notes, and it isn't hard to find the details on the web.) The results are occasionally surprising (ignore the subtitle, folks; it's a marketing ploy), but the explanation's usually convincing.
The book has endnotes which are tied to the text, but no pointers within the text to those notes. They're quite good, if you think to look at them.
Unfortunately, the book's pretty dull. Only Nate Silver writes clearly, though I rather like James Click's chapters. At the other extreme, Neil deMause says some valuable things about baseball economics, but I generally find him unreadable.
This review has also been published on a dabbler's journal. ( )