Really good book. Going to re-read it and catch all the stuff I missed.

Yes, there is repetition and yes, there are conflicting points made. One of these should be implicitly clear in the fact that it is a collection of essays and the other is made explicitly clear in the introduction. Seeing either as a negative is somewhat ridiculous seeing that those who hold to Reformed Theology not a monolithic body. There is much disagreement at the level of nuance.

But, what this book shows clearly and forcefully is a clear agreement on the overarching theme of whether children of believers are covenant members of the Church and whether they should receive the covenant sign.

Good book no matter where you fall on the issue. Well worth the read. ( )