I may read this again - something I rarely do - just for the description of voyage down the Hudson. ( )

Robert Pirsig's previous book ZEN AND THE ART OF MOTORCYCLE MAINTENANCE is a profoundly influential book in my own life. I have probably given copies of it as gifts to more people than any other book except my own. It is a powerful examination of the meaning of life in a pseudo-novelistic framework that makes the philosophical explorations both more palatable and more understandable. Pirsig's sequel, LILA, is an attempt to follow up and expand on the discoveries of the first book. While it is not an unsuccessful book, it is in large far less compelling, far less easily understood, and far less magical than ZEN.... The philosophy Pirsig explores is deeply complex and intricate, something that the first book managed to overcome. In LILA, there is some very rough slogging. The novelistic approach, in which the philosophy is presented as it bears on a presumably fictional story of a mentally ill young woman who falls into the company of the author's alter ego, Phaedrus, on a boat journey down the Hudson River. But only in the latter stages of this book does that story become fascinating, and in the meantime a great deal of effort must be made by minds no more advanced than mine to parse and come to grips with the ruminations on Pirsig's ideas about the Metaphysics of Quality. Pirsig wants to create a new understanding of morality, of good, and his arguments are often convincing, if confusing. Occasionally, some of his insights are riveting, as when he explains the real meaning and ramifications of Victorian morality. But for all its intelligence and eloquence, I fear this will be something of a disappointment to all but the most intellectual fans of ZEN AND THE ART OF MOTORCYCLE MAINTENANCE, which, still, 30 years after I first read it, is one of the most meaningful books in my life. ( )

Re-read half of this after reading it first 10 years ago. It's clear that he had a better/more aggressive editor on the first book.

& the way he writes about women…woof. ( )

I preferred this over the prequel Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. I found the storyline in between the philosophy much more interesting and thus made the philosophy much more relatable and interesting. I felt Phaedrus was more himself and more relatable as he had found a way to live and think as himself while bring accepted in society more than his previous character. This made him relatable. Definitely a book a would recommend to anyone interested in analyzing themselves or the world around them ( )

Even better than its more popular predecessor. All the parts I loved of the first book are expanded here! Full review forthcoming. ( )