Matty Jolson, the handsome new pastor of rural Georgia's Fountain Hope Baptist Church, hasn't been near a pulpit in six years. He was ousted from his last post after a woman he hardly knew became obsessed with him and took drastic action. And with a new congregation that isn't exactly thrilled to see him, the only bright spot of his job is Diane Tarver, the town's mousy librarian, who thinks he's drop-dead gorgeous. But Leah Littleton, one of Diane's best friends, also likes the look of him - and before long it looks like she might be bringing more drama his way...