Christine ChaundlerRezensionen

48NTE4TQ

398.22

Fifteen-year-old Geraldine Wilmott, nervous, shy, and much traumatized by a horrific experience during an air raid in the recent war (WWI), had been educated her entire life at home, and had only recently been cleared by her doctor to attend school. Unfortunately, her first term as a new girl, in the Lower Fifth at Wakehurst Priory, was a disaster from the very beginning. Inadvertently making enemies of the influential Phyllis Tressider and Dorothy Pemberton, when she was assigned to Dorothy's former cubicle in the Rose Dormitory, she soon found herself the target of a determined bullying campaign, made all the worse by her fear of everything from mice to hockey. Nicknamed "German Gerry" by her peers, because of her skill at speaking German, and relentlessly ridiculed, Gerry was the loneliest, most unhappy girl in the school. Even the kindness of head girl Muriel Paget, who took her under her wing, and coached her a bit with hockey, didn't seem to help...

Although I found Just Gerry to be an immensely engaging book, in many ways - it drew me right in, and kept me reading: so engrossed that I finished the book in one sitting - there is simply no denying that it is also a distasteful little period piece, full of nationalistic zeal (perhaps not surprising, given that this was published in 1920, between the two World Wars), and a particularly vicious kind of bullying and group culture. It was really very difficult to read of poor Gerry's travails, and not think of similar stories I have heard (or witnessed), that ended very sadly indeed. Of course there is a nominally 'happy' ending here (resting upon some supremely unlikely heroics), but it comes rather late in the story, and in no way compensates for all the ugliness that preceded it. It also rests on the conclusive demonstration of the fact that Gerry is not German, rather than on any recognition of the idea that persecuting someone for nationalistic reasons is both idiotic and ethically repugnant.**

I really struggled, when it came to rating this one, between two and three stars, only settling on three because the narrative did keep me so involved. I've read a number of school stories which, despite some dated elements, I would not hesitate to give to contemporary youngsters, but I don't think this would be amongst them. Unless as a history lesson, perhaps...

**I should note that, in addition to the almost ubiquitous anti-German sentiment throughout, which is used as an excuse to gang up on Gerry, there is also an anti-Semitic aside, in one of the scenes.

The story is a workmanlike adaptation for children, but the illustrations by Thomas Mackenzie are really rather fine, hence the 4-star rating.

An absolutely ripping yarn. ;) Maybe it's wrong to tag this as gay but it was entirely about a girl, Judy, who has an EPIC crush on one of her teachers. xD And keeps disgracing herself in front of said teacher! But of course it's all right in the end. I love the cover of this one so much - and the photograph Judy is holding? It's of the teacher she's crushing on, of course!

Rather spiffing little schoolgirl adventure tale - the Fourth Form are so determined to get ONE of the school shields, and think the sports one is in the bag - until one of the Fifths just narrowly beats them! So they're set to be the only form with no prize... unless they can snag the rarely awarded Valour prize. They set about trying to perform brave deeds with quite wonderfully disastrous results. ;) But of course all's well in the end - in a very unexpected way!

An absolutely ripping yarn. ;) Maybe it's wrong to tag this as gay but it was entirely about a girl, Judy, who has an EPIC crush on one of her teachers. xD And keeps disgracing herself in front of said teacher! But of course it's all right in the end. I love the cover of this one so much - and the photograph Judy is holding? It's of the teacher she's crushing on, of course!

Rather spiffing little schoolgirl adventure tale - the Fourth Form are so determined to get ONE of the school shields, and think the sports one is in the bag - until one of the Fifths just narrowly beats them! So they're set to be the only form with no prize... unless they can snag the rarely awarded Valour prize. They set about trying to perform brave deeds with quite wonderfully disastrous results. ;) But of course all's well in the end - in a very unexpected way!

An ancient volume from my childhood ~ illustrated by T. Mackenzie. Beautiful plates mounted on sugar paper, with a tissue sheet to protect the frontispiece (The Lady of the Lake, as per other 'cover' illus. here on LT). Approx. date ca. 1920 (pre-ISBN era).
I bought this off a 2nd hand box @ Foyles, Charing X Road. It was priced at £1 ~ & I just beat someone else to it! A bookseller offered me £45 for it, about 15 yrs ago, but I wasn't selling ...½

Arthur Waley