Autoren-Bilder
6 Werke 39 Mitglieder 3 Rezensionen

Werke von Duncan Curtis

Getagged

Wissenswertes

Für diesen Autor liegen noch keine Einträge mit "Wissenswertem" vor. Sie können helfen.

Mitglieder

Rezensionen

This review covers all three volumes on the F-86D/K/L. Starting with Volume I (Part 1) Design/Structure/Testing which is probably where this particular three-part set shines in terms of technical illustrations.
While a bit short on text Vol I has some excellent technical drawing including a few drawings of the radar of the symbology presented on the radar scope, a few excellent engine photographs including a nice detail shot of the iris assembly. Other stand out illustrations were the missile tray, Sidewinder development and a few panel shots lifted from the T.O.’S and some access panel drawings that coincidently show some interior structural details that will be of interest to modelers. Like any other Ginter production there are eight pages devoted to models of the F-86D/K/L.
There is sufficient text to provide the reader with an understanding of the problems encountered to give the aircraft the nickname of “Dog” Sabre but doesn’t really elaborate on the number of crashes or attempted solutions. The any reader that is interested in the J47 problems will have to seek that information elsewhere. Like the issues with the engine, any readers interested in the conversion from D to L in regards to the SAGE system will also have to look elsewhere for nuts and bolts technical details.
Volume II (Part 2) starts with about four pages of text covering the introduction of the aircraft to the Air Force and then launches into the standard Ginter format of a brief unit histories. Although the pictures are B&W, most of the unit histories do describe flash/stripe colors, etc. Also, there are a few oral histories of pilots describing their squadron experiences. One nice surprise was a history of bailment aircraft that were used for various purposes by both DoD and DoD contractors.
Volume III (Part 3) starts with a very brief overview of the introduction of the F-86D/L to the Air National Guard and the F-86K to foreign operators. The foreign operator’s chapter does not receive an introduction, just a simple history of operations for each receiving country in alphabetical order. Like Part 2, a few unit histories do describe flash/stripe colors but it’s not as consistent as in Part 2. From a historical perspective there are a few pictures in Part 3 that might be of interest such as formation photographs of mixed aircraft formations, underground shelters, various shots of test equipment in use, etc. Additionally, there is a review of a Revell kit F-86D kit that had been released since the publication of Part 1.
All three Parts (Volumes) are enthusiastically recommended for modelers, those interested in the nuts and bolts technical aspects of the airplane and anyone interested in the operational history of an airplane that that initially had a reputation as a “Dog” Sabre.
… (mehr)
 
Gekennzeichnet
jetcal1 | Sep 13, 2019 |
This review covers all three volumes on the F-86D/K/L. Starting with Volume I (Part 1) Design/Structure/Testing which is probably where this particular three-part set shines in terms of technical illustrations.
While a bit short on text Vol I has some excellent technical drawing including a few drawings of the radar of the symbology presented on the radar scope, a few excellent engine photographs including a nice detail shot of the iris assembly. Other stand out illustrations were the missile tray, Sidewinder development and a few panel shots lifted from the T.O.’S and some access panel drawings that coincidently show some interior structural details that will be of interest to modelers. Like any other Ginter production there are eight pages devoted to models of the F-86D/K/L.
There is sufficient text to provide the reader with an understanding of the problems encountered to give the aircraft the nickname of “Dog” Sabre but doesn’t really elaborate on the number of crashes or attempted solutions. The any reader that is interested in the J47 problems will have to seek that information elsewhere. Like the issues with the engine, any readers interested in the conversion from D to L in regards to the SAGE system will also have to look elsewhere for nuts and bolts technical details.
Volume II (Part 2) starts with about four pages of text covering the introduction of the aircraft to the Air Force and then launches into the standard Ginter format of a brief unit histories. Although the pictures are B&W, most of the unit histories do describe flash/stripe colors, etc. Also, there are a few oral histories of pilots describing their squadron experiences. One nice surprise was a history of bailment aircraft that were used for various purposes by both DoD and DoD contractors.
Volume III (Part 3) starts with a very brief overview of the introduction of the F-86D/L to the Air National Guard and the F-86K to foreign operators. The foreign operator’s chapter does not receive an introduction, just a simple history of operations for each receiving country in alphabetical order. Like Part 2, a few unit histories do describe flash/stripe colors but it’s not as consistent as in Part 2. From a historical perspective there are a few pictures in Part 3 that might be of interest such as formation photographs of mixed aircraft formations, underground shelters, various shots of test equipment in use, etc. Additionally, there is a review of a Revell kit F-86D kit that had been released since the publication of Part 1.
All three Parts (Volumes) are enthusiastically recommended for modelers, those interested in the nuts and bolts technical aspects of the airplane and anyone interested in the operational history of an airplane that that initially had a reputation as a “Dog” Sabre.
… (mehr)
 
Gekennzeichnet
jetcal1 | Sep 13, 2019 |
Excellent Overview of an Outlier Sabre
Now an old Naval Fighters (NF) volume with a 2001 publication date this monograph provides a great history of F-86 target conversion and operations including multiple pages devoted to the conversion process with two excellent block diagrams devoted to telemetry, ground control and “auto recovery” functions and controls. If you’re looking for the typical NF detail drawings of details such as landing gear or the cockpit, you’ll be disappointed. However, for someone doing a conversion there are few photos interspersed throughout the volume that may be of use including a few pictures on page 48 that maybe of help to someone opening up the left hand or nose panels. Also included is a serial number listing which may be of interest to “train spotters” or modelers interested in doing a model of a particular Sabre.
While this is an excellent addition to a dedicated F-86 library, I cannot recommend it for modelers unless converting to a target aircraft. Highly recommended for Sabre aficionados, anyone interested in Flight Safety International, or the navy aerial target program.
… (mehr)
 
Gekennzeichnet
jetcal1 | Sep 1, 2019 |

Statistikseite

Werke
6
Mitglieder
39
Beliebtheit
#376,657
Bewertung
4.1
Rezensionen
3
ISBNs
6