Marian Hurd McNeelyRezensionen

Working a homestead in South Dakota in 1910 would be hard for anyone. Yet, four orphaned sibilings are put to the task. If you enjoy reading books like Little House on the Prairie, you will enjoy following the story of these four as they battle weather, bad neighbors, claim jumping, and the worry of having enough money to take them all the way to establishing their claim.
No matter whether you are 12 or 20, you will find yourself turning the pages of this book enthralled with the story Marian Hurd McNeely has created.
---Le Coeur de l'Artiste

First published in 1929, and chosen as one of six Newbery Honor Books in 1930 - along with A Daughter of the Seine, Pran of Albania, The Tangle-Coated Horse and Other Tales, Vaino: A Boy of New Finland, and Little Blacknose - Marian Hurd McNeely's The Jumping-Off Place is an immensely engaging work of historical fiction, which follows the story of four young homesteaders in South Dakota, in the early years of the twentieth century. When their beloved Uncle Jim dies, the four Linville siblings - Becky, Dick, Phil and Joan - decide to follow his plan (elaborately outlined in a notebook left for them) to homestead out west, on South Dakota's newly opened Rosebud Reservation. Leaving behind their home in Platteville, Wisconsin, they head for the endless prairie, where they encounter back-breaking work, daunting weather, and a family of hostile claim-jumpers whose many acts of vandalism and intimidation range from broken windows to assault. They also encounter community, a beautiful land, a new sense of purpose (in the case of Becky's school-teaching), and a place they can call their own...

I enjoyed The Jumping-Off Place - named for Dallas, South Dakota, the last "jumping-off" place before heading into the prairie - immensely, gobbling it down in two days! It immediately grabs the reader's attention, and doesn't let go. Some of the incidents - as when Phil and Autie Wubber are hung over the side of a butte by (presumably) the nefarious Welps - are very serious indeed, but the overall feeling is cheerful, with a sense of hope, and of adapting to new circumstances, prevalent throughout. I admired all four Linville children, and the other homesteaders - how hard they worked! - and can understand why the South Dakota State Historical Society reprinted the book, in 2008, as it documents an important aspect of the history of that part of the country. I also understand why this has been compared favorably with Laura Ingalls Wilder's Little House books (McNeely's was published first).

That said, this is not entirely unproblematic, as a story for contemporary children. Teachers, parents and librarians should note that there is mention of "dirty Indians," and "working like a n*gger," in the course of the story. The former appears once, spoken by Aunt Jule, whom the children do not like, and who is a character held up to ridicule by the narrative. Although the children themselves later see Indians, on the train, they themselves do not refer to them, or think of them (as far as the narrative indicates) in this way. The latter also appears once, in a casual remark about working hard, and - in the absence of any African-American characters - does not seem to indicate any specific racial animus on the part of characters or author. Still, thoughtful adults should probably be aware of this, and stand ready to discuss the issue of changing ideas about race and language, with young readers. They might also want to discuss the historical reality behind this story - the theft of treaty land that makes the homesteading possible in the first place - as it is not something that the author references in any way.

Despite these issues, The Jumping-Off Place is worth reading, both for its own story, and for its depiction of a specific place and time, and a specific experience. I understand that McNeely based it upon her own life, and that really shines through in the narrative, which is convincing, and at times moving.

Four orphaned children set off to settle their uncle's claim in South Dakota by living on the land for 14 months. They endure the hardships of the prairie, including a squatter living on the land who does spiteful things to them and their neighbors. Because of the setting and the connection to homesteading, readers are certain to compare the book to the Little House books by Laura Ingalls Wilder, but the time periods of the settlement are different. This book was actually written before the Little House books. One must remember the time period in which this book was written when reading some of the words in the book. As a librarian, my favorite part of the book was when the library was developed. This was a quite pleasant read and certainly deserved the Newbery Honor that it was awarded. It is far more readable and will be appreciated more by today's younger readers than many other Newbery Medal and Honor books of that period.

Early in the 20th century, four orphaned children from small town Wisconsin carry out their recently deceased uncle's plans for homesteading in South Dakota. Their uncle lingered long enough after a stroke to provide detailed instructions for the children to follow. To fulfill the requirements for homesteaders, they must live on the property for 14 months and cultivate at least 10 acres. Once they gain title to the claim, they can sell it and use the income from the sale to get a good start in life.

Although none of the four children are twins, the book reminded me a lot of the Bobbsey Twins books I loved as a child. The children pair up in the same way as the Bobbsey Twins. Seventeen-year-old Becky and 15-year-old Dick work well as a team to manage the family finances and household chores. Preteens Phil and Joan have chores to do, but they also have time for school and play.

The language of the book hasn't aged quite as well as the story. A couple of references to Native Americans and African Americans are typical for that era but wouldn't be used by today's authors for children. This would be a quick and enjoyable way for family historians to learn about homesteaders and homesteading in the early 20th century.½

Discovering this book was a lovely surprise, and I wish I had read it when I was in my grade-school Laura Ingalls Wilder phase. Homesteading is really the only thing The Jumping-Off Place has in common with the Little House books, besides the location in South Dakota and the centrality of family, and it is written with a slightly older reader in mind. It's a pity that Marian Hurd McNeely died so young, and that this is the only book of hers to be both in print and readily available in libraries and bookstores.½

The Jumping-Off Place tells the story of four orphaned siblings, who set off to South Dakota to homestead, fulfilling their late uncle's dream. Homesteading is filled with challenges, but the four children stick together and manage to make it through the long, hard winter.
The book did take a bit to get into, but after the first few chapters the story moved right along. The character of Becky, the oldest sibling, is very likable, but the younger children especially were not ver developed. The book is filled with wonderful descriptions of the South Dakota prairie.
This particular edition is accompanied with an afterword by Jean Patrick, valuable for its background information about the author and book, as well as about homesteading during that time.

I very much enjoyed this tale of four orphans carrying on their late uncles dream of homesteading in South Dakota. While modern readers will find it reminiscent of the Little House of the Prairie books, it was written several years earlier, and is set several decades later, in the early 20th century. Some of the language used is rather dated, and will require explanation for younger readers, but I recommend this book despite the occasional phrase which is sour to the modern ear.

Last night and today I have been enjoying this story, first published in 1929 and republished this year by the South Dakota State Historical Press for a new generation of readers. (The cover pictured here is from the older edition since the new paperback cover is not available at Amazon.) Little House on the Prairie fans who have exhausted Ms. WIlder’s canon and all its spin-offs, should try this story of a family of four orphan children who take up a homestead in South Dakota, determined to hold down their claim for fourteen months until they can gain title to the 160 acres of South Dakota farm left to them by their beloved Uncle Jim. Uncle Jim’s death at the beginning of the story gives the children a grief that is slow to heal, but the words and plans that he left them guide them in their new life on the prairie.

Read the remainder of my review at my blog, Semicolon.

“The Jumping-Off Place” is the story of four siblings who set out to homestead their uncle’s land in South Dakota. They are all very young, but grow up quickly through their experiences. The book details some of the hardships of life as a homesteader, but also shows the beauty of the land and the camaraderie of those who “prove it up.” The story is sweet, easy to read, and appropriate for younger children. It reminds me of the “Little House” series, but, as the afterward makes clear, “The Jumping-Off Place” was published three years earlier than Wilder’s books. Unlike the "Little House" books, "The Jumping-Off Place" doesn't suffer from tediously long descriptions of prairie life, but still offers many interesting details. I would recommend this to anyone interested in this historical time period. It would be an easy read for middle grade students and a nice read-aloud for younger children.

After the death of their beloved uncle, four orphaned siblings settle a homesteading claim in South Dakota in 1910. Led by their older teen sister, Becky, they spend their first year on the prairie. Originally published in 1929, this is definitely an old fashioned children's book, and it is very reminiscent of the Little House series. The book starts off a little slowly, but Hurd McNeely develops her characters very well-- quietly but quickly--and i found my self pulled deeper into a story that is quiet but consistent-- chronicling events --not adventures, exactly-- that occur during the family's first year on the claim. The story ends when the year finishes, and while the ending is certainly predictable, it is also satisfying-- and in keeping with the quiet nature of the work itself. I really enjoyed the book --- it is very well written and full of subtleties that enhance the story without hitting you over the head-- for example, the seasonal weather on the prairie mirrors the mood of the narrative as it progresses. i knew little about South Dakota or the prairie experience before The Jumping-Off Place and i did not expect to like the book anywhere near as much as i did, and i have a new found understanding for the settler experience. When i talk about this book and this period, however, I do feel compelled to point out that this was the last of the large native american land thefts, and this land ----that the Linville kids and other prairie families so loved-- was stolen from native people as part of US policy to decimate the Indian population, separate the people from their ancestral lands and destroy native culture. I believe the book's afterward, by Jean L. S. Patrick, should have made this point more clearly. So....that being said, I clearly liked the book quite a bit, and while it is not for every child, i think that for upper elementary and middle school kids with a taste for the Little House series, or A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, or Secret Garden, etc. I would recommend it. Also, a great Read-A-Loud for a younger group. Recommended-with historical notes--

After the death of their uncle, the four Linville children move out to the South Dakota land their uncle had claimed as a homestead. The children learn to grow up quickly and together while facing the difficulties of maintaining a new territory.

At first I found this book to be tedious, wandering aimlessly as the prairie wind it so accurately described. Soon, however, I came to appreciate the characters as they demonstrated strength and depth that was not evident in the first pages.

I moved from the New England area to the Midwest and so I fully understood the torment one can feel when buffeted by the constant wind. The battle against the wind served as the perfect symbol for the battles the Linvilles faced while "proving up" their homestead. The close-knit community formed between the settlers living around the Linvilles rings true to the Midwest atmosphere, giving the reader a sense of comfort and hope while escaping into the lost world of homesteading.

"The Jumping Off Place" is set in the early 1900's. It is reminiscent of the "Little House" books. I was actually surprised to learn that it was written before the "Little House" series. This book is a re-release by the South Dakota Historical Society of a book originally published in 1929. It was given the "Newberry Honor" title in 1930.

In "The Jumping Off Place", four orphaned children set off to fulfill their late uncle's dream of homesteading in the Dakotas. They had planned to have their uncle with them. However, an untimely stroke and his resulting death left them setting off on their own to "prove up" his claim. This story is about their determination to make it through 14 months despite hardships common to homesteading, unexpected trials such as a contest on their claim by neighbors intent on causing trouble, and the Dakota weather.

I found "The Jumping Off Place" to be a very refreshing book. It was a very pleasant read absent of much of the language and innuendo you find today-even in youth or young adult books. There was so much detail that it was very easy to picture oneself there with them; as if you were a fly on the wall. The reader gets to see the children grow into young adults as they deal with the death of their uncle while going through their homesteading venture.

My 9yr old daughter picked up this book to read after I had finished. She said it was very hard to get into the book. She also said the "old-fashioned" language was a bit hard to understand. According to her, the book was easier to read and "less boring" after she got past the first couple of chapters. (It should be noted here that she loves the "Little House" series and is always reading everything she can get her hands on; especially historical fiction.)

The younger reader may find it hard to follow if they don't already understand the premise behind homesteading. A short history lesson might make it an easier read for the younger set. A parent should also be available while the younger set is reading the book to answer any questions they may have regarding the story line or some of the language used. It's not bad, it's just not typical of today.

The biographical information on the author at the back help the reader to better understand the times from which the author came. The short glossary provided at the end serves to help the younger reader better understand some of the language of the time. However, I think it would have been MUCH more helpful to list this at the front of the book as some younger children won't notice it listed on the Table of Contents. My daughter would have found the book easier to read much sooner had she noticed the word list before she started. She found it very helpful once I pointed it out to her.

I would recommend "The Jumping Off Place" to older children and adults who enjoy historical fiction. I would recommend it to younger children only with an adult present to point out the word list and be ready with any questions they may have.

This is a great book that, while being similar to Little House on the Prairie, still has its own unique voice in telling the story of South Dakota pioneers. I really enjoyed the book and thought that it was a great read both for fun and for historical interest. There are not very many books that take place in South Dakota, especially during the 1910s, and this book is an excellent example of the writing of that time and of the history of that time and place.

I have taken to reading the Newbery winners and Newbery honor books through the years. I am so sorry I missed this one until now. South Dakota State Historical Society has reprinted it and I am so glad. I won this in LibraryThing's Early Reviewers and started on it right away. At first it struck me as similar to Laura Ingalls Wilder's Little House books which were a favorite when I was a child. I actually wrote to Mrs. Wilder when I was in fourth grade and I got back a photo and information. I quickly turned to the copyright and saw it was written before The Little House books.
It is a delightful story about four children who after the death of their uncle go to South Dakota to take up his homestead. It has wonderful characters that add to the story.McNeely writes with grace and you fall in love with this family and their struggle on the prairie. I will be recommending it to those who love historical fiction whether they are children or not.

I began to read The Jumping-Off Place by book light in a camp bunk with barely a glance at the cover. There was a lovely old-fashioned quality to the writing and the characters that surprised me, until I looked more closely the next day and realized that the book was written in 1929.

This is a wonderful story, set in one of the last bits of the frontier after the turn of the twentieth century. Four orphans, having just lost their beloved uncle, travel to South Dakota to "prove up" his claim. They face hardships--drought, blizzard, wind, and an adversarial neighbor--with maturity, hard work, generosity, and an unquenchable spirit. In the process they fell in love with the prairie and the community and it with them.

This is an excellent book for all ages. It would make a very nice family read aloud, particularly because there is some lovely prose. The original illustrations have been retained and enhance the historical feel of the book. The South Dakota State Historical Society has added an afterword with historical background and author information and a word list, adding to the educational value of the book.

This 1930 Newbery Honor Book was a joy, and I am very glad that the SDSHS Press has decided to return it to print.

The Jumping-Off Place is an older pioneer classic that truly deserves to be reprinted. While some may see it as a take-off on Little House on the Prairie, it was actually written beforehand. Four siblings, ranging from 17-8, work and play on a small homestead, well-planned by their deceased uncle. They live well, not just survive, a drought and a blizzard, despite troublesome neighbors and a distant busybody aunt. The kids are realistic, playing, joking, and teasing eachother instead of the stereotypical always-perfect or bratty children.

The Jumping-Off Place was a Newbery Honor book in 1930, and this lovely new edition is published by the South Dakota State Historical Society Press. I'm glad they have reprinted it, because it's a very well-written story, reminiscient of Laura Ingalls Wilder's Little House books. But as Jean Patrick writes in the afterword, McNeely's book was written in 1929, three years before Wilder started publishing her books. And McNeely's story takes place about thirty years after the time period that Wilder wrote about.

The title is taken from the name of the end of the railroad line where the children get off. It is more than just a place where the track ends; it is where you step off onto the prairie and take responsibility for your own survival. Four orphaned siblings — Becky, Dick, Phil, and Joan Linville — had been planning to move out to South Dakota's Tripp County to "prove up" a claim there with their Uncle Jim. But a few months before they were to start, Uncle Jim had a stroke. During the long months of his illness, he never gave up the dream he had for the children to continue with the plan. He filled a notebook with a month-by-month summary of what the children would need to do in order to survive on the prairie for the fourteen months they would have to stay. And then he died.

Becky, age 17, is the head of the little family now, and they decide to carry on with Uncle Jim's plan by themselves. Once there, the Linvilles find that the struggle to survive would be even harder than they thought. There is another family, the Welps, that has laid claim to their land, and the Welps have no compunctions about vandalizing the children's property and even trying to cause Phil's death. This hostility and the harsh conditions of prairie life almost make the children give up. They have a number of unexpected expenses, and it seems like they are going to run out of food during the winter, until Becky is offered the position of schoolteacher for the area's children.

Although she has no formal training, Becky takes on the challenge and becomes well-beloved by all the neighbors for her patience and good sense. On one occasion the children are caught in a prairie blizzard, and Becky keeps them alive by forcing them to march, march, march all night long in the schoolhouse. It is pleasing to see the community appreciate her worth and stand by her in the feud with the low-life Welps. On another occasion, Becky gets to see firsthand the squalor and poverty of some of the prairie settlers, when the Olesons' baby dies of a snakebite. Becky helps to clean the house and lay out the little child, even giving up her one beautiful nightgown to make a burying dress for the little child. This sad chapter is very well-handled by McNeely and is written in a way that does not sugarcoat the reality of death and sorrow. But there is no despair, somehow, and I don't think young readers will be crushed under the weight of the sadness.

I found the writing style very graceful. On the second page, as soon as McNeely wrote that "it was not often that fifteen and seventeen worked together so silently or so soberly," I knew I was in for a lovely read. McNeely has such a spare, apt way of describing the relationships among the children and the way Becky in particular views her neighbors. McNeely's prose never falters. I love the part when Joan is contemplating the beauty of phosphorescence for the first time:

Phosphorescence was a grown-up explanation; it was just as well not to dispute it. But one might have one's own thoughts. And Joan, stumbling over the dusky prairie at Becky's side, knew that she was to live for fourteen months in a wonder world, where fairy lights shone at night and fairy folk danced at the side of a creek.

Lovely.

Some modern readers may claim that the children are too good to be real and that Becky's selfless commitment to the needs of others is too idealistic and unbelievable. I disagree with that assessment. Becky has a rough time dealing with the heat during the prairie summer, and becomes very irritable as she tries to control her emotions. And her assessments of Dick are also telling; before the proving-up forced him to become a man, he was a rather thoughtless boy who was interested in little besides his athletic pursuits and his friends. And right from the beginning McNeely's characterizations are realistic; when their unpleasant Aunt Jule appears to discourage them from carrying out their plan, the children know that she makes a good point when she says they may be able to settle the land, but who will settle their fights? The Linvilles' decision to try to get over the petty things that cause arguments is portrayed as something of a struggle for them. These children aren't too good to be true — they are like us, and they deal with their problems in ways that we could (and should) emulate. It is not that they are too virtuous; it is that we have come to expect too little of ourselves.

I should also mention William Siegel's lovely illustrations. They fit the feel of the story perfectly. The picture of Becky at the Oleson's house was particularly poignant. Overall, this is a wonderful book with believable characters, a good story, and graceful prose to carry it along. I highly recommend it, and I look forward to sharing it with my children someday.

Thank you to the South Dakota State Historical Society Press and the LibraryThing Early Reviewer program for the opportunity to review this book!

Just days after their uncle's death, four orphaned children follow through with their uncle's plans to claim a homestead on the newly opened South Dakota territory in 1910.
This is an outstanding historical fiction book about the westward expansion, homesteading, and pioneer life. Also outstanding is the story of the children learning responsibility, courage, and perseverance, as well as learning how to deal nobly and wisely with nasty, wicked people. A charming, heart-warming story that realistically shows the children struggle to not squabble as they realize their increased dependence on each other without their uncle and in their harsh new land. Originally published in 1929 and truly worthy of the Newbery Honor award.

I greatly enjoyed this book about a family of siblings in pioneering days on the South Dakota plains.

It is well written with just the right amount of tension about what's going to happen to the family, without detracting from the sense that the life described was how it was for many people.

I shall definitely be keeping this book!

It's a lovely book, a keeper.

It was published in 1929, and the South Dakota State Historical Society republished it this year. The year after it was originally published it was named a Newberry Honor book (Hitty, Her First Hundred Years was the Newberry Winner that year). Laura INgalls Wilder would not publish the first of her Little House books until three years after The Jumping Off Place was published, and yet they are very similar, undoubtedly because of the authors shared experience homesteading in the Dakotas.

This is the story of siblings Becky, Dick, Phil, and Joan, two teens and their younger siblings, who fight out a plan to homestead in the Dakotas. The children have been orphaned and reared by their uncle who dies just before the story begins, and before the blended family can complete their plans to homestead in the Dakotas. The uncle has a lingering illness, giving him time to go over those plans with the four children as they decide to go on ahead and settle the claim on their own.

This story, probably best enjoyed alone by children 8-12 or as a family read-aloud, has all the true grit, elements of personal responsibility, hard work, can-do ethics, and charm of the Little House books, the Prairie tales of Bess Streeter Aldrich, the Five Little Peppers, and Understood Betsy. Indeed, Dorothy Canfield Fisher (who wrote Understood Betsy) admired The Jumping Off Place and other work by its author, Marian Hurd McNeely. The main character is the oldest girl, but there is enough about the oldest boy that I think this story might interest boys as well.

It was published in 1929, so there are a few phrases we wouldn't use today (an upright person of integrity is described as white on two or three occasions), and they are settling on an INdian Reservation that's been opened up for homesteading and nothing is said to indicate this troubles anybody. But these issues are easily addressed and do not diminish the book, especially given the charm of the literary language and the plucky little family who people the book.

The children battle claim jumpers, loneliness, drought, wind, unexpected expenses, a run away cow, and rattlesnakes. A neighbor's child dies and the teenaged protagonist has to help with the laying out. In need of extra cash for the home-stead expenses which mount up more quickly than they planned for, Becky takes on the local school and must face down the bullies- she also saves the lives of her youngest students when they are caught unexpectedly in a deadly blizzard. They also have to learn to get along and work harder and bicker less. Their winning pluck and determination earn this book a place on our shelves, and maybe yours, too. It's definitely worth the shelf space.

There is also an afterword by Jean L. S. Patrick, who gives us some interesting biographical information about Mrs. McNeely, as well as geographical and historical.