Michael Bungay StanierRezensionen

Dense with insights and an extremely practical book.

When approached with an issue, most of us instinctively respond with doling out advice. We assume that people want to use our expertise. However, many of the best leaders have a different response: curiosity about the other person. They ask questions to empower the people around them to make better decisions. After all, the question-askers are the ones closest to the issues, not the one being questioned. In this book, Michael Bungay Stanier seeks to reorient leaders towards this approach of empowerment so that they can lead more effectively.

Asking questions develops the human component of the situation better instead of merely providing a “quick fix.” This approach doesn’t fit every situation, but it does help most of them. He explores how to change habits and then specific questions that can approach problems with this attitude of curiosity. These questions are not merely imagined but are practically based on seminars that he leads. The questions are frankly good and worth meditating on. I use some of them already, but others – like “What did you learn from this?” – are ones that I hope to adopt in my life soon. They apply not only to business situations, but also to life more generally.

The main limitation of this book is its brevity. It identifies key questions well, and it contains some deeper digressions into empirical research behind their effectiveness. Those are interesting and good, but I wanted still more depth, whether in the form of anecdotes, more research, or something else. I’m not sure where I’d suggest that the author go, but each question needed more fleshing out in my judgment. I’d cut some of the marketing hype in the text and expand it with better expansion of the ideas.

This book addresses primarily leaders in the workplace, but these questions also apply to those who want to improve the quality of interpersonal interactions in their personal life. Effective listening is an art disappearing in American life. We can broadcast and market ourselves all the time, but it takes skill to use others’ broadcasting to achieve important goals. Reading books like these to bring out others’ best effort can distinguish the next generation of leaders. It can even give them a competitive advantage in the marketplace.

For a short book the amount of repetition is crazy. There is some good info in the book but I did find it a bit painful to persevere through it. 2.5/5

Straightforward advice, hands on tips and lessons that make sense.

Thought-provoking, and seems to be easily applicable.

I have read a few of these types of books recently. Their central premise is asking better questions in a way that elicits better responses from individuals without triggering defensiveness. Frankly they all seem to offer sensible advice as does this book. The questions are all solid. Many other currently trendy bits of self-help are rolled in too, with reference to many excellent external resources. I also like the setup at the end of each chapter for habit formation to carry over some of these new behaviours. There is however nothing startling here, but it is educational and offers the opportunity to learn more. With the information in the book it is probably worth more than 3 stars but it is not so good or useful that it is worthy of 4........

Summary: Kicking the advice habit, asking questions well, and using variations of seven key questions can lead to more effective leadership coaching.

Over the next few weeks, I will be mixing in reviews of books on coaching, part of some reading I am doing for my own development. I'll take the risk of reviewing these because all of us influence others in some way, and it is never a loss to learn how we might do that with greater effectiveness that helps others flourish.

One of the key ideas of this delightfully straightforward and easy to read book is that many leaders tend to give directions, answers, and advice far more than ask questions. This thwarts effectiveness by promoting dependency rather than autonomy in those we lead. It leads to more time being absorbed in this unproductive activity, and at worst, leaders become bottlenecks in their organizations.

Another critical insight is that deciding to ask more and better questions is not enough if the leader doesn't recognize what triggers the advice-giving habit. With each of the seven questions that follow, the author asks us to identify the triggers that activate habits that derail us from good coaching and to identify a new practice that will be come a new habit.

The core of the book is seven great coaching questions:

1. The Kickstart Question: "What's on your mind?" Ask this early, with a minimum of chit-chat and this gets to the reason for the conversation. Often this will be about one of the 3Ps: Projects, People, and Patterns, all linked to each other.

2. The AWE Question: "And what else?" This question draws out more information, often identifies more options, buys time, and keeps the "Advice Monster" at bay.

3. The Focus Question: What's the real challenge here for you? Often what is on one's mind is nebulous, or there are many challenges mentioned. This question gets concrete and personal and prevents "coaching the ghost" of discussing someone not in the room rather than what is facing the person in front of you.

4. The Foundation Question: "What do you want?" Often the coachee is not clear on this and it is not clear in the situation. Once clear, it is possible to have an adult conversation where it is possible to answer "yes," "no," "give me time to think about that," or perhaps, "not this, but that." Also, it is critical to recognize the difference between wants and needs, the latter often being the reasons behind the wants. The question can also be a mutual one, particularly in a management situation where two people can get clear on what each wants in a situation and then get on with figuring out how to respond to that.

5. The Lazy Question: "How can I help?" It question calls upon the person to make a direct request, and it delivers you from being the perpetual rescuer. A blunter way to ask this question is "What do you want from me?" Instead of deciding for a person how one can be helpful, it allows them to say what really would be helpful, and it allows you to decide whether you can offer that help. It is lazy because it saves us from providing all sorts of unwanted and counterproductive help.

6. The Strategic Question: "If you are saying yes to this, what are you saying no to?" This chapter offers some great help in figuring out how to say "no" when it is very hard to do. It also helps us figure out what we will be saying "no" to if we choose a strategic direction, and what else we may need to say "no" to in order to fully embrace the "yes" rather than over-commit.

7. The Learning Question: "What was most useful to you?" This recognizes that debriefing is where learning really takes place, and clarifies the most important outcomes to your discussion. It also has the side benefit of increasing the perception that the coach as useful!

Stanier includes psychological research at the end of each chapter explaining why the questions are effective. He also sandwiches a "Question Masterclass" between each question that explores how one asks questions as well as what questions we ask--things like cutting the intro and asking the question, sticking to "what" questions, getting comfortable with silence, listening to answers, and acknowledging them.

The questions ring true with my own leadership and coaching experience--these are good questions. The insight on the "advice monster" is one most leaders need to heed. There is a refreshing contempt for truisms like "work smarter, not harder." I do wonder about the author's claim that "Coaching is simple" and that this book will "give you most of what you need." Is this hype, or simply an author with a lot of chutzpah? What I can say is that this was a quick read, offered good questions and reasons for using them, and didn't bury its message in a ton of verbiage. That's worth something.

It was a good read.

Stanier says he took four years to write four versions of this. I'm virtually scratching my head at that...it's a trifold tract blown up with repetitious cliches, buzzwords, self-help stuff, and a lot of name- and book title-dropping. Stanier aggregates other people's works (he even cites the serial offender aggregator Daniel Goleman) into a whizzbang ask seven questions and you know everything about coaching leadership flipchart. I think he misses his target by a wide margin. Note: I do agree that asking questions is important. But asking questions is only the start of coaching leadership.

Maybe *I* missed his point. Perhaps he was trying to show someone how to coach others in leadership.

If you've never known a single thing about coaching leadership, I expect this will be a good start. If you know anything...pass on this.

This is a very interactive book. Michael Bungay Stanier starts by describing the difference between Bad Work (work that is pointless), Good Work (necessary, sometimes engaging, and mundane), and Great Work (meaningful, has an impact, makes a difference; inspires, stretches, and provokes). He argues that we often don't make deliberate choices to do more great work. Instead we follow other people's priorities into Good Work or even Bad Work.

To help us do more great work, Michael leads his readers through lots of introspective exercises to help them identify a great work project. In my management classes, I teach a little about how to find meaningful, intrinsically motivating work, and the principles in this book are very consistent with research evidence about meaningful work. But even though I've thought a lot about these ideas in theory, I learned a lot about myself when going through Michael's exercises. I definitely had some aha moments, and I appreciated the opportunity to think more about my own Great Work.

Although I applied this book to my work, it definitely applies to all types of life roles. We can do more great work at home, at church, and in our communities.½

Fantastic collection of essays! So many different topics from brainstorming to personal energy to being creative to being productive and so on. Many great authors were chosen and they gave some wonderful advice. This will definitely be a book I pick up again at some point to reread.

Some of the best take-aways were the simplest:

* Set aside blocks of time to work without interruptions (uninterrupted time is more productive; forget about the idea that multi-tasking is more efficient... In fact, measuring IQ before and after trying to complete a task with and without interruptions shows there is a 10 point performance drop in those who are constantly interrupted).
* Think about managing energy vs. time:
o Figure out what tasks can be done adequately... not everything needs to be done perfectly. "Good enough" can free up time for great work (I've been applying this rule to housework for years).
o Years ago I read a time management book that advocated getting by on one to two less hours of sleep a night, with the rationale being you'd net more time. Thankfully, research by Schwartz and others shows this approach is counter-productive. Over time, people who catch more zzzz's aren't just healthier and happier, they're actually more accomplished.

http://thingswelove2.blogspot.com/2011/04/stop-busywork-and-start-work-that.html

After hearing Michael Bungay Stanier talk about how to Do More Great Work: Stop the Busywork. Start the Work That Matters on the GTD Virtual Study Group, I had to read the book. It took me awhile to and I have to say I am glad I finally did. It is a very disciplined approach to finding what work is one's true calling, or Great Work.

Stanier contends there are three kinds of work: Bad, Good and Great. Bad work consists of those things we do that are a waste of time, energy and life. Good work is the familiar, useful, productive work we do day in and day out. Great work, however, is meaningful, has an impact and makes a difference. The idea is to eliminate bad work and spend more time on great work.

The book is short, only a couple hundred pages. Stanier has sprinkled in coaching stories and 'guest posts' by noted luminaries such as Seth Godin, Penelope Trunk and Leo Babauta amongst his material. It reads much like a blog with interesting tidbits thrown in to spice it up.

The stars of the show, of course, are the exercises. The book contains 15 maps designed to lead one through the process of discovering, defining, planning and executing their Great Work. Each exercise builds on the last and provides insight into the Great Work to be done.

I have read several books that give exercises, questionnaires or other assignments throughout. I am not one who likes to take the time to stop reading and do as I'm told. I will often read straight through, promising myself I will go back after I finish and do the exercises. I never do, though. Not once. This book is the first where I am actually doing the work. I did stop and do the first three exercises before plowing on to the end. Now that I am done, I want to go back and do then all.

Another feature of the book I really appreciate is the companion website and podcasts. Stanier has created short movies to help bring the point home. Also, the exercises are on the website as pdf files. This is a critical bonus to me as I don't like writing in books, much less exposing my deepest thoughts to whomever may come behind me and pick up the book. I like having those separate sheets to work with.

This is a book to be read, thought about, read again and acted upon. We all have Great Work to be done. I like the way Stanier guides through the process. The exercises unlock new ideas and helps make sure nothing is overlooked. These short activities (maybe 5 minutes each) are designed to provide insight. None are trite or useless. They are to-the-point, easy to do and push the reader to actually doing the Great Work. This book is well worth the time and money. Get out of the chair and go Do some Great Work.