This was a great comic. It had an immersive atmosphere and interesting characters, all fit for a self-contained adventure. ( )

The story is engaging, with suspenseful twists and great pacing. It feels true to the videogames, but not to Sopokowski's novels. The story erases Yennefer, Triss, and Ciri from Geralt's life, a major strike against it in my opinion. The artwork just flat out sucks. ( )

I thought this captured the vibes of The Witcher quite well with a horrific story to boot: Our Witcher Geralt comes across a lonely fisherman who becomes Geralt's travel companion. They travel into some dark woods and come across a house that they can't seem to escape, and for Geralt's companion his sins are about to be exposed.
The art style reminded me of Hellboy a bit, and fit the creepy story quite well. The characterization of Geralt was spot on with the books, games, and TV show. ( )

I didn't see the twist coming. Captures the tone and spirit of The Witcher world very well. Can't wait to play TW3! ( )

3.5*, verging slightly closer to 4* than 3*. So a fun read and a good graphic novel. The illustrations were good and thematic, a nice drawing style imo. I am not the biggest Witcher afficionado (no more one than most people these days) so I cannot comment as much on the writing not matching Geralt although I will say I didn't find the dialogue jarring which can be tricky for graphic novels. Not an overly complex curse but a fairly tense one nonetheless. ( )