Mostly positive. Author Tom Wessels is a professor of Ecology at the Antioch New England Graduate School, which puts my back up, lays my ears back, and bares my fangs. However, there’s no denunciation of capitalism or suggestion that the planet would be better off with a lot fewer humans. In a couple places, Wessels illustrates the maxim that a Concerned Environmentalist is somebody who built a trophy house in the mountains last year, while a Rapacious Developer is somebody who wants to build a trophy house in the mountains this year, but I’m not sure that I wouldn’t take that attitude myself.


The book is classical natural history, with Wessels wandering around various granite peaks in the US, doing a little geology and a lot of botany in the process. His descriptions are limited to glaciated peaks – thus the sites discussed are Acadia National Park, the White Mountains and Adirondacks in New Hampshire, the Wind River Range, the Beartooths, the Enchantment Mountains in the North Cascades, and Yosemite National Park. Wessels comments that there are granite mountains in the Southwest, but the ecology is completed different; erosion is by heating/cooling cycles rather than glacial polishing; he’s only interested in glacial peaks.


Wessels’ main focus is on the plant communities inhabiting the glacial balds – lichens, cryptogametes, krummholz conifers and higher plants capable of living in crevices and soil pockets – with a lot on ecological succession. We had a thread on “walking trees” somewhere; Wessels discusses a phenomenon previously unknown to me. A lot of altitude-adapted conifers can sprout roots from branches that touch the ground. A wind- and ice-blasted tree can grow new roots from branches on the downwind side; if the original trunk eventually dies a new one can form downwind. The process can repeat, leading to trees migrating hundreds of feet from their original site, sometimes leaving a trail of clones behind.


An anecdote illustrates the use of Federal rules to block Federal bureaucracy. A conservation group attempted to limit damage to plant communities by using fist-sized rocks to mark off trails on heavily frequented balds. Somebody – latter determined to be a hiking grandmother and her grandson – removed the marked trail borders and instead used the rocks to surround mark out areas of vegetation. This proved to be much more successful than marking trails; while a marked trail apparently provokes a desire to walk off it and demonstrate contempt for authority, the circumscribed vegetation areas remained undamaged – an illustration shows them looking sort of like a Zen garden. The Forest Service then acted on the No Good Deed Goes Unpunished principle and prepared to remove all the rocks; somebody – Wessels doesn’t say who, but my guess would be a university professor – countered by demanding that the USFS follow NEPA and prepare a formal Environmental Impact Statement. I know of one other case where NEPA was invoked for a human-modified situation, involving a spa outside Death Valley that was feeding water to a pothole supporting a population of desert pupfish. In this case, the Forest Service didn’t even bother to attempt an EIS and the rock-bordered “gardens” remained. I’m sympathetic to gaming the system like this.


This isn’t a guidebook; although Wessels mentions many plants, he doesn’t provide identification keys (although the scientific names are listed in the Appendix). I assume he doesn’t want enthusiastic amateur botanists busy collecting specimens – lichens, in particular, are pretty difficult to identify without microscopic examination. There are no photographs except the cover; all the illustrations are pencil drawings. The bibliography is a little sparse. Pleasant enough to read but more of a personal memoir than something useful in the field. ( )

I have now learned a few things about granite that are interesting enough for me to have read almost the entire book. Wessels style is quite accessible to the novice and he shares his knowledge in such a way as to appeal to a much wider audience than he may be receiving at this time. I admit that when I reached the point in The Granite Landscape when Wessels dives deep into conservation efforts and the evil trekkers that crush the helpless lichens that future generations may never see - I closed the book. I realize that I am in the generation that is supposed to care about everything for the sake of my down-line family and their "some day" children but I am not caring enough to read about it. All said, I found that the book worth reading and I recommend it to anyone with questions about a segment of geology and American natural history. ( )

150 DOU 1