"No era buena cosa ser capturado vivo por ellos", Jacinto Antón, El País 05.06.2023: https://elpais.com/cultura/2023-06-05/no-era-buena-cosa-ser-capturado-vivo-por-e...

I was first introduced to Paul Andrew Hutton back in the 90s when he appeared as a "talking head" on A&E's Civil War Journal series. He served as editor of the trade paperback Eyewitness to the Civil War series, which included some classic titles of CW literature, including JL Chamberlain's Passing of the Armies. But his CW work is more of a side gig to his major works on the history of the American West and Southwest, and he ranks as one of that theater's main historians. I was living in Arizona when I acquired Apache Wars, so it was truly local history reading much of it. As an academic, Hutton's work is not for the casual reader (which does not bother me in the least as I am not a fan of "popular history"), but his research into and knowledge of his subject matter is quite deep. Familiarity with the geographic areas referred to in the text are of course helpful, but not a requirement. This ranks as unquestionably the best volume on the subject matter and is one of Hutton's finest works. ( )

Great historical non-fiction. Hutton will be added to my list of authors to watch. ( )

In 1851, an Apache warrior named Goyahkla found his entire family massacred by Mexican militia men. This warrior, believing the justice of his revenge earned him the protection of the gods, would embark on a lifetime of violent retribution. The name he would become known by was not his own, but (a bit perversely) the name of the saint his Mexican victims prayed to when he attacked: Geronimo. Ten years later, a young boy, Felix Ward, was abducted in an Apache raid on his parent’s ranch. These two figures would contribute to a war between the Apaches and the American government that would last for decades.

This is an incredible history, and one which has largely been forgotten (at least in my east-of-the-Mississippi neck of the woods). While the name Geronimo is known to many (though to most as the word that is shouted before jumping from a high place), few know the details of the Apache resistance to American and Mexican encroachment. Like many Native American histories, it is a part of the past that has been de-emphasized in school curricula.

The story is stunning, and devastating. The duplicity and racism of the American government, while not surprising, is nauseating to read about in such detail. The bad-faith deals, the continual shunting of the Apache onto smaller and smaller portions of land, the corruption of the Indian Agents assigned to their “care,” the selling of troublesome Apaches into slavery, it’s all there in black and white. And it’s horrifying.

This is a well-written history, but keep in mind that this is more of an academically-inclined book. The story is an incredible one, but in this tone, it does become dry and dragging at times. History buffs and those interested in the topic will find an incredible trove of information here. Those looking for a more accessible version of the story should check out Indeh, written by Ethan Hawke and illustrated by Greg Ruth (Which made my Top 10 for 2016).

A copy of this book was provided by the publisher via Blogging for Books in exchange for an honest review. ( )

This is a fuller account than the ones I have read elsewhere (e.g. Tom Horn's memoirs) of the entire struggle between the US military and the Apaches, starting with the events leading to the Gadsden Purchase which gave the US title to much of the Apache lands and going down to the last alleged sightings of the Apache Kid after 1900. It is written with respect for many of the fighters and other leaders on both sides, though it is also clear on the brutality which also existed on both sides, and gives a balanced view of both the virtues and the faults (often self-righteousness) of attempted reformers like O.O. Howard and John Clum. ( )