Not bad. Not the best book I've read either. All in all, I consider it a good book. ( )

Clement’s later novels included females because people had pointed out to him that his novels had no females in them. To be fair, his work is not ardently sexist; it was just often focused on a group of scientists going to an alien planet to study the aliens ... and at the time Clement was writing, "group of scientists" largely meant "group of male scientists". There are female characters in “Iceworld”, and also in “Needle”, but those are set on Earth (with the aliens visiting us), where a complete absence of female characters would be a bit glaring. I think 'Needle' would be an interesting book to make a film from ... and (spoiler alert) given that the aliens are just amorphous blobs that live inside the body of a human host, it wouldn't be that expensive to make. If it had been the point of the book, a space-mission with fewer than 40% female crew would have been a different story and, concomitantly, much longer if added to the voyage to Mesklin. The humans are there as a backdrop for the Mesklinites and have to be as schematic as they are to fit the word-count. A space-mission with a few women would have been a good premise for a story (see the cover-story for that first issue of 'Universe' I mentioned in a post a while back) but akin to something like a woman accompanying Shackleton to the Pole. Who knows how many stories like that were spiked because of John W. Campbell's notoriously prissy secretary?

On the other hand, "Through the Eye of the Needle" is, if anything, more filmic than the first book. Well, the hero of “Needle” had a mother, though she only got a bit part.

But this wasn't unique to Clement. Eric Frank Russell was much the same, though in racial matters he was quite advanced. In Arthur C. Clarke's “Earthlight” the hero's wife is mentioned a few times, but never appears on stage. It was much the same with Verne and Wells, where Weena in “The Time Machine” is the only female character I can think of.

NB: I always enjoyed the SF of Hal Clement. Then someone pointed out to me - after I had read a few of his novels without noticing it - that his novels contained no female characters at all. Untrue. 'Noise' and 'Still River' off the top of my head. And the male pronouns applied to Barlennon and 'his' crew by Lackland/the narrator might not apply. I wonder why “Mission of Gravity” hasn't been optioned by Pixar. Admittedly Barlennon's a bit like Mr. Krabs from 'Spongebob' but maybe a character who communicates with farts is a bit advanced for Disney's shareholders.

SF = Speculative Fiction. ( )

I picked this up (along with the sequel) in the Gateway SF sale last year, having had these in paperback for many years. Clement was noted for writing SF that was completely hard science-based and firmly rooted in the plausible. This book (and the sequel) are unusual in that they are set on Earth and are near future rather than an alien world and far future. It was originally published in 1950 and reads very much like it’s set in that era.

Both an alien hunter and the criminal of his species that it is pursuing crash land on Earth. The story is written from the viewpoint of the alien and details his effort to survive and to fulfil his mission despite being marooned with none of his advanced technology.

The twist is that the alien species are protoplasmic lumps that spend most of their time in symbiosis with other species, generally (but not invariably) intelligent. The Hunter enters into symbiosis with a 15-year old boy, Robert Kinnaird, whose parents live on a tropical island producing bio-oils.

While a great read, there are a number of problems:

1. No female characters. The only females mentioned are Bob’s mother, the sisters of another character, and the nurse at Bob’s boarding school back in the US.

2. Technology is rooted in the 1950s, so slide rules not calculators. However, the bio-oil is produced by specially-bred bacteria.

3. Although there is a school on the island, Bob attends boarding school. It’s possible this is to do with Bob’s father being in a senior role on the island.

Recommended, but with reservations. (Please also see the review on the sequel - Through the Eye of a Needle.)

One of the first completely non-anthropomorphic (and yet engagingly human) aliens in science fiction. A bit dated in terms of human society, but still a fun read of a detective story where neither the detective nor his quarry are human. ( )

Reading this oldie but goodie again after many years, what struck me most was that Clement depicted a group of 15 year old boys interested in nature, swimming, construction--everything but girls! A measure I think of how our culture has changed. This is that rare thing, a science fiction mystery. ( )