The edition I read is the Candlewick Treasure, illustrated by [a:Wendy Anderson Halperin|61581|Wendy Anderson Halperin|http://www.goodreads.com/images/nophoto/nophoto-F-50x66.jpg]. I don't think the story would work well with plain text, but Halperin made it seem lovely. I, personally, didn't thrill to it, or feel as moved by it, as Halperin surely was. I don't know why. Barbara Cooney is also a wonderful illustrator and probably did a great job in the edition she illustrated. I do recommend either to other tree-huggers, birders, and nature- and animal-lovers. ( )

This charming short story is akin to a fairy tale for adults. A case may be made for deeper metaphorical meanings, but this tale should be enjoyed simply for what it is. A girl, when asked to betray a beautiful creature, is not swayed by gain but makes up her own mind. A wonderful tale of trust and right. ( )