Ben BlackerRezensionen

I had to stop reading this — it’s chock full of swearing!

This was great but mostly because I'm already a huge fan of the podcast so read all of the stories in the voices of the characters. I'm not sure if it would hold up on its own.

That said, the podcast is free and amazing so, you know, go listen to it and then read this book. You won't regret doing either.

The Thrilling Adventure Hour is a long-running stage-show and podcast with an old-fashioned radio-drama sensibility. Every episode features recurring characters and serial adventures acted out by actors and comedians in front of a live audience. Although some familiarity with the podcast is helpful – hearing Paul F. Tompkins’ voice in your head as you read can only improve your enjoyment – this graphic novel version of the show doesn’t require much familiarity with the source material. I’ve actually only listened to a handful of episodes, and none of them were recent.

Luckily, the show transitions well from stage to page. The writing is sharp, and the illustrations for each story are done by a different artist with a unique style. The book has a total of ten stories featuring the regular characters from the show. Each story takes its cues from common tropes of bygone radio dramas, then subverts them with humor. That mix of nostalgia and comedy might wear thin if it wasn’t clear how much affection the writers have for their subjects. I’m sure it also helps that these characters and stories were honed over eight years of live performances.

My favorite of the bunch is easily the story of booze-hounds Frank and Sadie Doyle, who solve paranormal mysteries by accident while searching for their next drink with charming disregard for danger. However, I also thoroughly enjoyed Down in Moonshine Holler, with its cross of Preston Sturges and Shirley Jackson. My favorite joke was the Murdermen, though. Always in the mood for murder.

The best part about this collection is that it’s the perfect primer for someone who has never heard of the show. They can read and enjoy it, then dive in to the show’s archives in iTunes. I know I certainly will. I’m also hoping to get a chance to see the live show sometime soon now that I live in Los Angeles.

The idea behind this sounded really interesting, a coven of witches are controlled by a group of male witch hunters into this whole suburbanian housewife life.

But sadly it just wasn’t executed right. It was Painfully boring through most of the comic, the dialogue was filled with so many moments that made me cringe with distaste and roll my eyes. Took way to long for the women to discover what was going on, and then the punishments they lashed out just made no sense. It was discombobulated towards the end. And those ending outfits the girls had on where full of cringe, it was almost like the illustrator was making fun of witches.

I give it two stars for the art being well done (minus those ending outfits)

Delightful as the podcast, which also means some segments bore me as much as others amuse me endlessly. The fake ads, likewise, are awesome. This was a well-done adaptation of audio play to visual format that was familiar (and included some of the same gags, tweaked to suit the format) without reading like a script (unlike the merely decent Welcome to Night Vale novelization). Not an easy feat!

This book was hoot and I really enjoyed it. Lots of clever banter between the characters and all the narrators were extremely good. Totally unbelievable but that's what makes it so good. Highly recommended for fun.½

Unfunny and Distasteful
Review of the Audible Original audiobook edition (Jan. 30, 2020)

The subject matter of live organ theft is distasteful enough on its own to earn a "One Star" / "Did Not Like" rating, but the unfunny mindless back and forth banter here really sunk this supposed "light-hearted dark comedy."

It was actually shocking that fairly big-named actors such as Meg Ryan and Ed Begley Jr. would associate themselves with this project.

Cut and Run was one of the free Audible Originals available to Audible members for the month of February 2020. It is available to everyone for a standard price.

This one was just okay. The story is that the witches keep coming back every 100 years and generations of men keep trying to destroy them. The illustrations were great but it was way too violent and gory for my tastes. The only reason I finished it was due to the story when their memories were erased. That was the only saving grace of the comic which is why it got 2 stars. The daughter was my favorite character because she could talk to the cats and the cats!! They were awesome! Just sayin...

ARC courtesy of Diamond Book Distributors, via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.