Saleem Crawford

Alternate history ranks among the more robust genres in science fiction, as authors frequently explore the consequences of what might have happened had historical events taken a different turn. Far less common, however, are what might be termed alternate stories: other takes on notable fictional works. While both Marvel and DC have explored the possibilities in such storytelling (in their "What If" and "Elseworlds" titles respectively), for the most part it's a form little seen outside of comic books. Thus, for Dark Horse Publishing to undertake alternate storytelling of the famous "Original Trilogy" of Star Wars movies marks something of a novelty. In three separate limited-series comics (brought together here in a single omnibus volume) their writers and artists envision what might have happened had events in some of the most famous movies in history had taken a slightly different turn.

The first of these comics builds upon the events of the fourth film, A New Hope. In it, the proton torpedoes Luke Skywalker fires into the exhaust vent only damage rather than destroy the Death Star. With the Rebel base on Yavin-4 destroyed and Princess Leia recaptured by Darth Vader, Luke travels to Dagobah to begin his training with Yoda. This sets up an interesting dynamic, with Vader attempting to turn Leia to the Dark Side while Luke more readily embraces his training to become a Jedi. Yet the ending leaves something to be desired, with the resolution just a little too pat for my tastes.

In the second of these tales, the focus is on the events and the characters featured in The Empire Strikes Back. Here the divergence is a small event with enormous consequences, with Han Solo's tauntaun dying before he can locate Luke in Hoth's frigid wastes. Luke's own subsequent death from exposure because of this sets of a new chain of events, with Han, Leia, and Chewbacca fleeing directly to Bespin before going to Dagobah themselves. This was by far my favorite of the three, both for Dave Land's story (which is inventive while remaining true to the elements of the movie) and for how he develops Leia as a Jedi, which allows him to explore the possibilities of what is by far the most disappointingly unexplored aspect of the entire Star Wars franchise.

It would be hard to top Land's story, and the final comic, which is based on Return of the Jedi, emulates the film in the franchise by falling short of its predecessor's high standard. In this story, the team's failure to rescue Han Solo from Jabba the Hutt's fortress forces Luke and Leia to continue their search for his carbonized body. While this alters events somewhat, the story's divergence is considerably less than that of the two previous ones, with the final events for the most part playing out as they did in the movie. Though the ending is interesting, it's something of a letdown after the more creative explorations in the first two series, even if it does end up fitting in with the pattern of the original trilogy of films.… (mehr)

Star Wars takes its turn to do the whole "what if?" conceit. If you've read a DC Elseworlds comic or Kim Newman's Anno Dracula books, you'll know the idea. Each of the three stories collected here takes a different one of the films from the original Star Wars trilogy, changes a single event and shows how the story unfolds from there. Usually while exercising the prerogative to have everything go to pot in the most spectacular way possible. What if the Rebels had failed to destroy the Death Star? What if Luke had died on Hoth? What if Leia's attempt to rescue Han from Jabba got screwed up?

The three series were originally published separately and I'm not sure reading them together does them any favours. Some of the ideas turn up two or three times: the trip to Dagobah, Leia becoming a Jedi, the Skywalker family revelations.

But you also realise the quality of each story isn't necessarily dependant on to what degree it deviates from the one we know: A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back are easily the two stronger contributions, but while the former delivers epic spectacle by deviating immensely from the original story, the latter has a lot of fun rewriting Empire as a runabout, with characters turning up at the wrong moments for their bits of the plot. Return of the Jedi never manages spectacle or fun, mirroring the plot of the film while making minor tweaks that ultimately don't feel important.

Writing a what-if story places an onus on the author to not only come up with an alternative series of events, but one that still feels true to the characters and has some tragicomic resonance as a result. Star Wars Omnibus: Infinities probably holds as much interest as a case study in storytelling as it does an exercise in tickling the belly of the fans.… (mehr)

What if Luke had failed to destroy the Death Star? Or if he'd died before Han could rescue him in Empire Strikes Back? Or what if Jabba's Palace had blown up before Leia could save Han? The three graphic stories collected here explore what might have happened if one thing had been changed in the original Star Wars trilogy.

All three have different artists and writers, so each story has its own flavor. There's a good amount of nods to the movies themselves, in quotes and in action (poor Vader, always losing limbs). The first one is the most straightforward and probably the best. It's worth noting that, in all three of these, Leia gets to play an expanded role.

Recommended for Star Wars fans of all ages, genders, and species.… (mehr)