Max I. DimontRezensionen

i had heard about this book for years, but it is very outdated and provided a great deal of incorrect information. i read it in short segments, hoping to find a portion that was factual. dimont portrays the Jews hagiographically, and that buries much truth. he also downplays antisemitism, which has been a real problem throughout jewish history. i would definitely not recommend this book!

I read this book some time ago and forgot to enter it. However, it was quite good.

A relatively thin book on a huge topic, the story of a religion which has had tremendous influence on the world. Given the scale, it is cursory in some areas, but a beginning for the student of the area. I would label it as useful rather than insightful.

I have had this book a long time, and recently rediscovered it on my bookshelf. I think I bought it at a thrift store. It is a used paperback in poor condition; the back cover is missing, but I don't know if any of the pages are lost. The index ends with the Vs, and it is possible that there was originally more. Seems like the word "Yiddish" would have been included.

I started reading it because I have been curious about the history of the Jewish people since Biblical times. Now I am still in the Biblical era in my reading, and am unhappy. The author conjectures things that are contrary to Scripture. Sometimes I'm tempted to skip over until after the Roman destruction of the Temple, but I probably will continue as I am doing.

I have concern over some of the statements made like when the author states that archeologist classify people into four races based on skin color (chapter one). It's my understanding that the idea of distinct races has been shown to be false and while the book was first published in the 1980s I would think that a revised and corrected copy could be published.

A very concise history of the Jewish people in less than 200 pages and it is a very fast and easy read (about an hour for me). I cannot believe that this is something that took six hours to finish discussing in class and we barely spoke about most of the book. It's not incredibly detailed (but neither was the class we used it for). I would rather have several books that go into more depth, however if you just need a summary of the Jewish people's history, this will do.½

A comprehensive history of the Jewish people, which views that history as a part of world history rather than as an isolated narrative. It clarifies much of the early history of Israel/Judea, putting the Bible stories I learned as a child into the world-historical context that I have since adopted. The book also discusses Jewish religious belief and practice over the centuries in an accessible manner. Finally, it is an enjoyable book to read.

Topics in Jewish history

Jewish history presented as a series of adventures

This was required reading, but looking back on it im not sure why... its a pretty brief and somewhat smug look at the history of the Jews from Abraham to the state of Israel.

This takes the 30,000 mile high view of Jewish history and thought, and looks at some of the transformations and consistencies throughout.

This book definitely has opinions and smug/snarky remarks. But it comes across as biased and perhaps due to its brevity isn't backed up with where more depth can be gained in a particular area of interest.

That being said, it's usefulness to me is to provide me with that broad overview of Jewish history - including the permutations of the religious and philosophical thought as well as the interactions with the nations and peoples that Jewish people have found themselves in contact and persecution over the centuries. The overview is useful for someone like me now, who has forgotten more than I care to admit and would like to go back and revisit interesting areas of history in the future, and this provides a crude and rudimentary place to start.

[This review also appears on FingerFlow.com, a site for review and discussion of creative works.]

Jews, God and History is a phenomenal work which undertakes the difficult and tedious task of presenting the 4,000 year history of the Jewish people. Instead of presenting this history from an insulated point of view, author Max I. Dimont shows the history of the Jews in the context of the entire world; in the vast tapestry of human history on this planet, the Jewish people are shown to be a strand that makes its way through every corner of the fabric.

Dimont immediately draws the attention of the reader in his introduction, musing about how such a small population of people have had such influence on the greater world. Some of the most influential people in history were Jews: Moses, Jesus, Paul, Baruch Spinoza, Karl Marx, Sigmund Freud, Albert Einstein. Two of the largest world religions, Christianity and Islam, grew out of Judaism. The Jews introduced to the world the concepts of monotheism, prayer, church, redemption, universal education and charity. Perhaps the most interesting idea that Dimont brings up in his introduction is the age of the Jewish civilization; whereas all the other pagan civilizations that existed at the time have long since disappeared, the Jews are still around today. Dimont goes on to say,

"The Chinese, Hindu, and Egyptian peoples are the only ones living today who are as old as the Jewish people. But these three civilizations had only one main cultural period, and their impact on succeeding civilizations has not been great. They contained neither the seeds for their own rebirth nor the seeds for the birth of other civilizations. Unlike the Jews, they were not driven out of their countries, nor did they face the problem of survival in alien lands. The Greeks and the Romans are the only other nations which have influenced the history of Western man as profoundly as the Jews. But the people who now dwell in Greece and Italy are not the same as those who dwelt in ancient Hellas and Rome."

Needless to say, these facts makes the reader wonder "what is so special about the Jews?" and Dimont makes his best effort to answer this question in the most scholarly way possible, even explaining eight different theories on interpreting history and how they apply to the Jewish people.

Although Dimont uses the Bible as a source for his telling of early Jewish history, he makes it clear that he is approaching the material from a secular standpoint. On the subject of Abraham having a vision from God, Dimont states that the most important part of the encounter is not if God actually appeared to Abraham or if Abraham dreamed up the whole thing; what matters is that Abraham decided that he had a covenant with God, and his descendants continued to have that covenant. Dimont stresses that this point so important that Jewish history is built on it: the covenant that the Jews believed they had with God gave them the will to survive as Jews, which is a main reason why the Jewish people didn't simply disappear into the many civilizations they lived in throughout history.

In the chapters where he describes the Jewish religion, Dimont really shines. He explains the beliefs, rituals and scholarship in a way that is both accurate and accessible to people completely new to the material. It is in these chapters that he describes a crucial moment in Jewish history: the shifting of the religion from sacrificial rituals in the temple to prayer, scholarship and the expansion of morality and justice. These changes were instrumental in the preservation of the Jewish people; without being near their temple and their High Priests, the Jews might have simply given up on their religion while in foreign lands (a fate that occurred to most of the pagan civilizations of the time).

I've learned so many fascinating things from this book that I want to go on and on about: the exchange of ideas between the Jews and the Greeks, the Jewish Reformation Movement, the vital role of Jewish people in medieval society, the Jewish influence on both capitalism and communism, etc. This book is crammed with information, but Dimont's lucid writing style and occasional injection of dry humor and wit definitely made this book much easier to read than your typical history tome. For both Jews and non-Jews alike, I think this book is a must-read if you have any interest in world history.

The best Jewish History book I have read.

I have read this book several times over the years, and keep coming back to it. As a historical account of the Jews throughout the ages, and the impact that they and their ideas have had on civilization, it is really excellent. It is written for the "layperson," not necessarily for the serious scholar, and so the writing is very accessible, even humorous at times.
Although the Jews are the "heroes" of the book, Dimont does not gloss over many of the less-than-stellar events in their history. He also attempts to report factually, without devolving into arguements on belief that are unwinnable. His focus is on the facts of history; at one point I believe he states something along the lines of "It doesn't matter if you believe Abraham spoke to G-d, aliens from another world, or dreamt it all up himself; the fact remains that people followed him, and that is the important thing."
I found the book both entertaining and educational, and will be keeping it in my library for many future re-readings.

I read this in high school and remember having a positive experience. I recently came back to it and found it to be a history of the Jewish people written from so many abstract angles...not the best.