Stefanie Green

As the author describes it, the Canadian model of assisted death, which requires active medical guidance and intervention, seems far more compassionate than the U.S. version of assisted suicide, which allows physicians to avoid malpractice by forcing an ill patient to do all the work themselves. This book could have been improved by more discussion of ethical issues, such as the pressure that some disabled people feel that they "should" end their lives, against their will, simply because society chooses not to support them, and the work of death doulas. The best parts of the book are the patients' views on death:

"If I cannot give consent to my own death, whose body is this? Who owns my life?"
"We're befriending death. We're holding it, we're witnessing it, we're taking it back into our own hands."

Recommended for all libraries.… (mehr)

This is a useful and accessible book for Canadians interested in learning about the issues, procedures, and early days of “MAiD” (Medical Assistance in Dying), which came into effect in 2016. An “accessible” book, however, is not equivalent to an easily read one. There are innumerable descriptions of human suffering and the doctor-author’s experiences providing MAiD. I could handle the book only in small doses.

Green is a former family physician who for many years worked long hospital shifts as a focused-practice maternity-and-neonatal-care clinician in Victoria, British Columbia. Gradually worn down by the hours and missing time with her family, she decided to transition—you guessed it—to a focused practice in euthanasia. No one actually wants to call the human version of this medical procedure “euthanasia” because of its association with eugenics, but euthanasia is precisely what it is. Green is one of the earliest providers of MAiD in Canada. Along with a small group of colleagues, most of them family medicine physicians, she was instrumental in developing protocols and procedures. Green talks about a somewhat surprising overlap between maternity care and medically assisted death—saying both provide the intensity and drama that she is drawn to—but I admit to finding her selection of a practice exclusively dedicated to helping people die questionable. I am doubtful about anyone’s ability to remain mentally well balanced long-term while performing only this work. I base this observation on a lot of personal experience being present for veterinary euthanasia, which is performed routinely. Few domesticated animals die a natural death. I’ve observed the toll euthanasia takes on veterinarians. It hardens many of them, sometimes alarmingly so.

As well as providing case studies and an exploration of ethical, psychosocial, and legal issues around MaiD, Green tells stories about her own upbringing and family, so this is a combo memoir/expository piece. I can hardly say I enjoyed the book. Indeed, I suspect anyone who has been involved in the care of a terminally ill friend or family member (even a nonhuman one) will find this book bordering on (if not fully) harrowing at times. It is valuable, certainly, but any recommendation should be accompanied by the caveat that it is intense.

Rating: 3.5 rounded down… (mehr)