Karl Ernest MeyerRezensionen

Fascinating account of Central Asia and the conflict to control the area waged primarily by Great Britain and Russia.

Very good but unfortunately a bit dated½

This was both fascinating and infuriating, not necessarily because of the the writing but the content. The China Collectors focuses on American collectors of Chinese art, which is sort of a niche thing to write about except it spans centuries from the early 1800s through today. There's echoes of the nineteenth century naturalists' attitude that art collectors seemed to share with the 'If we don't take this now to preserve, no one will see it in the future!' as an excuse to take priceless cave paintings and bas reliefs from walls of the Dunhuang caves. The modern new age trend towards the east as exotic mysticism is really only a historical rhyme of previous trends towards an Asian aesthetic. Bookending historical record are cases of how modern China is now a player in the art collecting world, full of both the newly rich looking to collect and a nationalist group looking to repatriate stolen goods.

I'm a tad bit torn because some of the looting is about as bad as the theft of the Elgin Marbles from Greece, but on the other hand having collections stateside means they're much more accessible to me in the future.

Well written account of American efforts to collect the finest examples of Chinese art for private and museum collections. Interesting accounts of the explorations for these works as well as the earliest art dealers who worked to export the cultural legacy of China. Turmoil within China aided in the removal of some of the finest works and the political history of China is integrated well into this fascinating story. Altogether, this is a fascinating look at one segment in the growth of encyclopedic museums in the U.S.

fascinating reading A history of the the wheelings and dealing done in the Middle East. Well researched and written. Favorite quote "Never had so few lost so much so stupidly and so fast."
Second favorite quote paraphrased "They are only a minority, who cares"½

If you are fascinated by Chinese art, you must read this book. North American museums actually house an amazing array of Chinese art, due to numerous expeditions by sea captains, missionaries, and museum curators over the years. Reading of the art throughout the ages, I got a better grasp of Chinese history -- the Opium Wars, the Boxer Rebellion, the Cultural Revolution. The book is not easy to read but it is fascinating.

Written in the early 1970s, so it is a little dated but nonetheless informative and well researched, The sub title is "the traffic iin art treasures ". Meyer was a journalist who specialized in archaeology. the style is that of careful but slightly sensationalizing investigative journalism . It is about questionable museums policies in purchase, acquisitions and disposals of works of art and antiquities , where reputations are made on discovery, identification research and pronouncements about works of art. Money underpins risk in thefts , illicit transactions and international trade.... With a good many middlemen taking cuts before the specific artifact is lauded and displayed to the innocent but culture hungry museum goer. The message is be wary of anyone offering you antique treasures in local bazaars, markets and street corners or rushing at you as you emerge from a pyramid. It had happened to all of us who travel in search of archaeological sites and a deeper knowledge of the human condition. This work raises questions about why people are acquisitive and why collect and why societies have museums . It also gives a sense of the huge transfer of material wealth from old world and ancient civilization to America and the new world. Good photographs, detailed case studies, comprehensive bibliographies and detailed appendices make this an authoritative text for its time and one that despite the time span is still worth owing, The author is on less sure ground when proposing solutions . Sadly illegal and undercounted trade in artifacts still happens though today I wonder how many antiquities have been recently manufactured to supply human greed?

An interesting account of the antiquities trade. A behind-the-scenes look at the illicit trade in antiquities and art. Somewhat dated, but still very interesting book. Also provides a look into the museum and art collector world of the 1960s and early 1970s.

Utterly gripping.

Central Asia and the Great Powers½