Jason L. RileyRezensionen

Well, it's about Sowell, but it isn't Sowell.

An excellent intellectual biography, with just enough biography biography thrown in. An excellent introduction to Thomas Sowell's thought, books, and reception by those who like him and those who disdain him. Kudos to Jason L. Riley for writing an important book. Sowell's big ideas on economics, race, and history are explained well, with suitable quotations from Sowell's works. It made me want to buy more of Sowell's books. I would only have liked to have seen some images and a bibliography of Sowell's books (and perhaps important papers and articles).

Certainly about his intellectual development; a good discussion of some of his earlier life and education. Seem like by the time he ended up doing his undergrad at Harvard the ex-marine was a bit too grownup to be fully assimilated by his schoolmates.

The greatest use of this book is to learn about the circumstances in which Sowell's various books were written.

Riley builds a strong case here. It's a bit of a rough start, but he gets a solid flow by the 3rd chapter. I really wish it had been written post-2016 though.

He argues for a "liberal" policy*, using "conservative"-type evidence. The following is my addition to his argument.

I spent 12 months closely observing illegal immigrants in California. I've seen all of his points proven. For the most part, illegal immigrants are law-abiding. Most violence and abuse from them are perpetrated from a minority of them. In other words, illegal immigrants are more likely to hurt other illegal immigrants because they know they won't go asking for help from the authorities. (#mybiasisshowing)

I would add that, if you want to decrease crime, it's easier to track legal citizens.

So, yes, I agree with him. Highly recommend the book. Read it. And share it with your friends.

*it's all conflated for me at the moment

Once upon a time, the NYT released a list of Anti-Racist books to read. Like a good bibliophile and researcher, I wrote them down and added them to my Goodreads list. At some point during the process, this book came up on the "people who have read this also read this" suggestion box. Being a firm believer in reading both sides of the story (the truth usually, for me, seems somewhere in the middle) I added it and toddled off to the library, enormous To-Read list of call #s in tow.

All of the books I wanted were checked out.*

But, in that same section, was this book (because it wasn't on the NYT list). So, after waffling a bit, picking up a few of [a:Thomas Sowell|2056|Thomas Sowell|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1230424337p2/2056.jpg] and [a:Stephen L. Carter|43656|Stephen L. Carter|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1341951242p2/43656.jpg] books, I added it to my pile where it haunted me for the next four weeks.

After reading it, I have come to the conclusion that the title is misleading. It should be "How Well-meaning People make it harder for Blacks to Succeed."**

This book, as well as [b:The Souls of Black Folk|318742|The Souls of Black Folk|W.E.B. Du Bois|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1309202855l/318742._SY75_.jpg|1137159], did a great deal for me in helping me to understand the ongoing ideological conflicts between [a:W.E.B. Du Bois|10710|W.E.B. Du Bois|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1211293877p2/10710.jpg] and [a:Booker T Washington|20155130|Booker T Washington|https://s.gr-assets.com/assets/nophoto/user/u_50x66-632230dc9882b4352d753eedf9396530.png]. In fact, that's how he started out. One of the best sections is, in fact, where he picks up where Du Bois leaves off(his history of racism in that book ends in 1903 when it was published) and gives you an in-depth look at facets throughout the 1940s that supported Jim Crow laws(in the working class and, more especially, in the North).

Some of these facets are still around today and effect, most noticeably, the public education system.

Gag.***

Also, his experiences of being stopped, frisked, racially-profiled are worth reading.

Anyway, as far as the writing is concerned, he needs to slow down and clarify in some chapters. There were times I had to flip back several pages to see what his original point was and several times I had to reread a sentence 3 times to get the meaning of it.

End Notes:
I really want to read his book [b:Let Them In: The Case for Open Borders|3243631|Let Them In The Case for Open Borders|Jason L. Riley|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1433843788l/3243631._SY75_.jpg|3278362] now.

Like any good coward, because this isn't going to be a popular book to read (in light of the title, current popular writers, etc.) I am hugely afraid to write this next sentence but, here goes: I highly recommend reading this book if you want to see the opposing view, if you want to see stats on some recent studies, etc. You can hate me/unfriend me now if you want...


*It only took 3 hours for people to swipe them off the shelves. That's how fast this swept the nation.
** Sorry. But some of those names dropped were definitely not Liberals. And, after what Stephen Carter observed of FDR in [b:Invisible: The Forgotten Story of the Black Woman Lawyer Who Took Down America's Most Powerful Mobster|33898873|Invisible The Forgotten Story of the Black Woman Lawyer Who Took Down America's Most Powerful Mobster|Stephen L. Carter|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1532468031l/33898873._SX50_.jpg|54863805] one is reminded that hypocrisy is a worldwide epidemic. :)
*** I don't need sources on this one. I have friends who confirm it.

This is the first time I have read a book by Jason Riley. The title, "Please Stop Helping Us", interested me. The whole premise of the book was exactly what the title said. Many of the policies enacted to help the black community (such as affirmative action and millions of dollars being spent on government programs) are not working. Programs (such as school choice and vouchers) that are highly beneficial to black and other minority youth are being denied to our country's children because of the powerful teacher's unions. America has been entrenched in these non-working programs for years. How will we be able to turn things around to the benefit of all?

Surprised that there was not a whole lot to disagree with...I guess my bottom line thinking is that I want society to have a social safety net instead of a anti-social noose for all Americans and for people worldwide who are affected by what happens in Washington, D.C. and I think progressive policies achieves this goal instead of regressive policies. With mainstream political parties it's difficult to discern the differences between the two.

A good introduction to some of the problems facing black Americans today. It's not structural racism, or segregation, or the ill-effects of slavery or Jim Crow: it's (a) cultural and (b) a poorly functioning government. He did not hit the welfare state as much as he should, but he did go a long way to proving that there is a cultural problem in the black community: few fathers, ghetto culture, distrust of society, hatred of education (aka "acting white"). He lays the perpetuation of such poor cultural attitudes at the feet of civil rights hucksters and politicians who benefit from the status quo. Cui bono? No?

Of course, preaching to the choir and will have little effect but to make conservative whites and conservative blacks nod in agreement.

A short essay that adds a forgotten part of African-American history. Surprisingly the book includes two short essays that at least have some (although not a lot) of disagreement with the author. Not usual for an author to include potential critics.

Although he makes some interesting points, the author has a decidedly heated and opinionated tone which, combined with lots of statistics which weren't properly referenced (he had a short bibliography at the end, but no endnotes or footnotes), kept me from being totally convinced. Which is funny, considering I am definitely not of the opinion that illegal immigrants are evil. Still, it was interesting to hear the "free-market" point of view. Too bad he couldn't do better with his statistic citation. I like to be able to verify someone's statistical claims.

During the '60s the shift from economic power and growth of human capital degenerated into the seizing of political power. The author demonstrates how with exponentially more African-Americans in politics and in leading American society the black poor have been left behind. He wants to revisit the failure of the black power movemeant to empower African-Americans.

A young Wall Street Journal editor decries the anti-immigration fervor that has seized many of his fellow conservatives. He presents punchy, fact-filled refutations of popular myths concerning the economic, social, cultural and security effects of letting willing workers cross our borders freely. The tone is a bit strident in places, though gentlemanly compared to many of the shrill advocates for the restrictionist side.½