Albert WoodfoxRezensionen

Woodfox was a Black Panther, who was wrongly convicted of the murder of a prison guard at the Angola prison in Louisiana. He spend 43 years in solitary confinement, finally released in 2016. This book was released in 2019; and gives details of his life, and in his struggles to have the conviction overturned, and the lengths that Louisiana went to to keep him incarcerated. Also about the struggle to limit the use of solitary confinement. He was amazingly able to keep his humanity through this. Sadly, he died of COVID in 2022, at age 75.

I would compare this book to [The Autobiography of Malcom X]. It really gives details about life in Angola prison. (horrifying)

One of the best books I have read .. This is a seminal achievement in the genre of autobiographies. I put this right up there with The Autobiography of Malcolm X. I also believe it has the cultural wallop of The Fire Next Time by James Baldwin.

This is an important book. A book that must be read by every American who believes in justice and our Constitution.

(30) This was hard to read for many reasons. Woodfox was one of the Angola 3, African-American men incarcerated in Louisiana's notorious Angola prison and railroaded into a conviction for killing a white prison guard for their political beliefs as Black Panthers. They were then kept in a maximum security site - essentially 'solitary confinement' for over 40 years. Solitary confinement doesn't actually mean what I thought it meant which was also eye-opening for me. I thought basically all prisoners lived in solitary confinement regardless and that they were let out for work, exercise, or classes. I didn't realize that most prisoners i.e. 'the general population' lived in communal barracks like the military. I thought solitary confinement was no contact; padded cell kind of thing (maybe like the dungeon they describe.) The horrible things that go on in prison are unconscionable. The odds that poor black kids can rise above the narrow vice-paved roads they are set on are pretty low. I am reminded of the amazing TV show 'The Wire,' that really changed my mind about adopting the 'bootstrap' mentality.

Woodfox and his two compatriots Herman, and King are amazing men. What he accomplished while imprisoned in the worst place is astounding. That he would go into prison a high-school drop out, junkie, petty criminal and come out an educated writer and activist who produces a Pulitzer-prize finalist autobiography is a testament to his strength and moral fiber. I have no doubt he is telling the truth. I continue to be disgusted by the attitude and politics of the Deep South. And I am no bleeding heart liberal either. Truth be told, I don't think what is called 'solitary confinement' is cruel and unusual - I just thought that was what being in prison meant. Although certainly I believe in rehabilitation, education, and vocation for prisoners which I guess was not being offered to Woodfox and others in CCR.

The writing itself was at times compelling, but at times repetitive and a bit all over the place. I really had a hard time with all the characters. People's names were introduced once without much explication and then referred back to pages and pages later and I had no recollection of who they were.This is why it escapes a higher rating for me - it was at times a bit of a chore to read. I do notice that the title says .. a biography; yet the author is listed as Woodfox and the book is about his life. It is written in the first person and the acknowledgments don't include any typee of ghost writer so I am assuming that the term Biography is meant in a general sense.

He says he wouldn't change a thing about his life. His experiences forged him to be the honorable man he became - so in a sense - he was rehabilitated. And yet, another intervention that didn't rob him of most of his natural life and freedom surely could have worked too. I don't have all the answers and I believe the solutions need to come from leaders of the communities that are most affected but are rooted in equal opportunities for all.

An important book. I am going to redouble my efforts over the next year to read Ellison, Baldwin, and other important books like 'The New Jim Crow,' and reread 'The Autobiography of Malcolm X,' which changed my worldview when I read it many, many years ago. Amazing courage...

What a powerful book. Albert Woodfox spent 40 years in solitary confinement innocent of any crime that would warrant that sort of inhuman punishment. The things he endured and saw happen to others are unimaginable. It is truly horrifying and embarrassing that these type of atrocities take place in our country. We can do better. We need to do better.

Solitary is a long read, but absolutely a book with reading. Albert is not an author, but it is a story so powerful it transcends the need for writing perfection. If this book doesn't leave you wondering what is wrong with our justice system and prison system you might want to reevaluate your values.

"The need to be treated with human dignity touches everyone. And the key to resistance is unity"

Wow. 40 years in solitary. Not sure how he could do it. Talk about cruel and unusual punishment. What a mockery of the justice system as well. Seems like they tried to railroad him every chance they could. So sorry waht he had to go through. As a country - cant we do better? Also sparked me to learn more about the Black Panthers.

This was a tough, really brutal, read. It's difficult swallow decades of miscarried justice and incomprehensible to think about remaing unbroken by it. Albert Woodfox carries us through his entire life to show how he got to this point. I am not big into autobiographies or memoirs, and I felt at points that some of the conventions of the genre held Woodfox back from keeping the story moving. I think it's worth the read, though I had several editing suggestions in mind as I read.

Not a fan. First of all, it is not very well written or well edited. It goes into far too much detail, for example, on various court cases, even including extensive transcripts. All of that is unnecessary. Hinton's "The Sun Does Shine: How I Found Life and Freedom on Death Row" is better written and more persuasive.

Second, I just had a problem with Woodfox himself. Before being arrested, he routinely made armed robberies and assaulted people. And yet at least twice in the book he says that he regrets nothing:

> I have been asked many times what I would change about my life. My answer is always the same: "Not one thing."

I don't understand this. He doesn't seem to realize the effects of his crimes on others. For example,

> When I needed money, I went out and got it from a person walking down the street. I was a stickup artist … After robbing people on the streets and jacking dope pushers I eventually started robbing bars and grocery stores while they were open. I walked into a bar, pointed the gun at the bartender or somebody sitting at the bar, and yelled, "Nobody move, motherfucker. I'll kill you." … An unarmed deputy was seated next to the control panel. As soon as the doors closed I pulled the gun from my pants with my free hand and held it to his head. I told him to keep the doors closed and take us to the basement or I would shoot him. I didn't mean it but that's what I said

And yet, he also writes,

> "I used to think I kept getting arrested because I had bad luck," I told them. "It wasn't bad luck. I was targeted because I am black, that's why I kept getting arrested."

I get the sense from the book that Woodfox is highly self-absorbed. The book is about him, and only him. He seems to have mythologized himself as a civil rights warrior. It's good that this attitude got him through prison, but it's hard to read past his ego. Until the last chapter, everything is about him alone (and sometimes two others at Angola). The last chapter broadens the scale to criminal justice reform, but in a very unconvincing way. One is far better off reading Alexander's "The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness".

> To those of you who have spent years struggling for human rights and social justice: Don't give up. Look at me and see how the strength and determination of the human spirit defy all evil. For 44 years I defied the state of Louisiana and the Department of Corrections. Their main objective was to break my spirit. They did not break me. I have witnessed the horrors of man's cruelty to man. I did not lose my humanity. I bear the scars of beatings, loneliness, isolation, and persecution. I am also marked by every kindness.

More quotes:

> Malik got word to me from Oakland that we should start a separate chapter of the party—a prison chapter—at Angola. Before I left Orleans Parish Prison, I took an oath on C-1 to become a member of the Black Panther Party. On my last day there, one of the Panthers gave me a copy of the Little Red Book, a collection of quotations from Mao Tse-tung.

> I thought it was sad that I had to come to prison to find out there were great African Americans in this country and in this world, and to find role models that I should have had available to me in school. What helped me was that I knew I wasn't a criminal anymore. I considered myself to be a political prisoner. Not in the sense that I was incarcerated for a political crime, but because of a political system that had failed me terribly as an individual and a citizen in this country.

> Our resistance gave us an identity. Our identity gave us strength. Our strength gave us an unbreakable will. My determination not to be broken was stronger than any other part of me, stronger than anything they did to me.

> They thought they would stop our organizing by separating us but all they did was spread our influence. Wherever they put us, we started over, organizing our tiers. Pooling resources. Educating prisoners. Setting examples by our own conduct. In this way, we taught men the power of unity.

> I'd been framed for murder, persecuted at my trial, and wrongfully convicted. But I didn't feel like a sacrificial lamb. I felt like a member of the Black Panther Party. If anything, I had become more of a revolutionary than I was before

> Since Judge Tanner had overturned my murder conviction in 1992, my sentence at Angola went from life in prison back to the 50-year sentence I was serving for armed robbery. On April 29, 1996, I was discharged from Angola on that original 50-year sentence, having done 25 years—half the time, which was all that was required. If I hadn't been framed for Miller's murder I would have gone home that day. Instead, I packed up my possessions. I was to be transferred to a jail in Tangipahoa Parish, where I'd be held during my second trial.

> If I knew everything that was going to happen to me and I could turn back the hands of time, I would not change one thing about my life—not one moment of dedication, not one moment of struggle, not one moment of physical pain that I've suffered from beatings by prison people in New York and in Angola.

> In all the years I was at Angola, I'd been on so many hunger strikes I can't count them, yet I was never written up for one. They wrote me up for "defiance" or "disobedience" or "aggravated disobedience." They didn't want a record of our protests.

> I don't know if they overmedicated people, or if it was the nature of the drug, but Prolixin almost made men immobile. It broke my heart to see men on this drug. It would take them damn near an hour to walk from one end of the hall to another. They stopped taking showers. Their cells became filthy. Drugs like this were referred to as "chemical restraints."

> I can tell you that it changes you—the grief overwhelms you, the "what ifs" haunt you. And now I have to live with another tragedy—the two innocent men, who have already spent 36 years in solitary confinement, who remain in prison for a crime that they did not commit. This is a tragedy that the state of Louisiana seems willing to live with. I am not. I hope you aren't either. . . . After over 36 years, there can be no excuse to deny justice for one more day. It is time for the state of Louisiana to finally compare the bloody prints found at the crime scene to every inmate who was incarcerated at Angola on the date of Brent's murder and find out who left his fingerprint on the wall of that prison dormitory before he walked out and left Brent there to die.

This is the painful but ultimately inspirational story of a man's fight to overcome the cards he was dealt most of which weren't his fault. He is not a choirboy in his youth but ultimately what lands him in solitary confinement for forty years is a murder in prison that he did not commit. This book is also an indictment of the criminal justice system and the failures of the criminal justice system toward people of color. But to go through all he did and keep his values and mental acuity is a testament to the human spirit.

When Albert Woodfox was incarcerated and sentenced to quite a stretch in jail, he didn't know what to think, really; he was a teenager who'd got muddled up in basic criminal teenage stuff.

One of Woodfox's great strengths is his ability to express himself straightforwardly, without mucking up a line. As here:

The first time I was called a nigger by a white person I was around 12. I was waiting with dozens of other kids at the end of the Mardi Gras parade behind the Municipal Auditorium where the people on the floats, who were all white in those days, gave away whatever beads and trinkets they had left. On one of the floats the man tossing the trinkets was holding a real beautiful strand of pearl-colored beads. I thought they’d make a nice gift for my mom on her birthday. I called out to him, “Hey mister, hey mister,” and reached out my hand.

He pointed to me as he held the beads above his head and tossed them toward me. As the beads came close to me I reached up and a white girl standing next to me put her hand up and caught them at the same time I did. I didn’t let go. I gestured to the man on the float and told her, “Hey, he was throwing the beads to me.” I told her I wanted to give them to my mom. She looked at the man on the float who was still pointing at me, then she ripped the beads apart and called me nigger. The pain I felt from that young white girl calling me nigger will be with me forever.

Also:

At night, we stood under a streetlight on the corner of Dumaine and Robertson and talked shit for hours, boasting about things we never did, describing girls we never knew.

It's a fair shake to a man who can describe aeons of time in a single line.

I cannot even get into the innards of what happened to Woodfox, but he does a great job at showing what went down in Angola, a big American jail, where he went in the 1960s:

If you were raped at Angola, or what was called “turned out,” your life in prison was virtually over. You became a “gal-boy,” a possession of your rapist. You’d be sold, pimped, used, and abused by your rapist and even some guards. Your only way out was to kill yourself or kill your rapist. If you killed your rapist you’d be free of human bondage within the confines of the prison forever, but in exchange, you’d most likely be convicted of murder, so you’d have to spend the rest of your life at Angola.

Some orderlies, inmate guards, and freeman who worked at RC sold the names of young and weak new arrivals to sexual predators in the prison population. I had to be much more confident than I felt to keep guys from trying stupid shit with me. I couldn’t look weak. I couldn’t show any fear. So I faked it. Luckily, I had a reputation as a fighter who never gave up. There were prisoners at Angola I had known on the street and who knew me or knew of me. Word spreads quickly in prison. Dudes gossiped and talked. Word was if you whip my ass today you have to whip it again tomorrow. You have to beat me every day for the rest of your life if necessary. That helped me a lot.

Just those two paragraphs put the fear of Bog in me.

This is quite the book to go well together with Shane Bauer's excellent exposé of the privately-owned prisons in the USA; that book is named "American Prison".

One of the greatest hardships for me the first few months I was at Angola was getting used to the sameness of every day.

The hardest job I ever had in my life was cutting sugarcane, Angola’s main crop. Cutting cane was so brutal that prisoners would pay somebody to break their hands, legs, or ankles, or they would cut themselves during cane season, to get out of doing it. There were old-timers at Angola who made good money breaking prisoners’ bones so men could get out of work.

And that's just the start.

Woodfox's political being starts becoming awakened due to meeting persons who taught him of The Black Panthers, and what they wanted to teach (and learn). This changed matters inside:

We practiced martial arts together on the tier. We read aloud. We held math classes, spelling classes. We talked about what was going on in the world. Every Friday we passed out a spelling or math test. We encouraged debates and conversation. We told each man he had a say. “Stand up for yourself,” we told them, “for your own self-esteem, for your own dignity.” Even the roughest, most hardened person usually responds when you see the dignity and humanity in him and ask him to see it for himself. “The guards will retaliate,” we said, “but we will always face that together.”

Where the book goes slightly not-good, is where Woodfox goes deeply into his own case; while I see how the details are important to him, I personally feel the book should have been edited tighter; my mind had a hard time staying focused on all of the minutiae, the majority of which I will not be taking with me to my grave. In a larger context, sure, I can see how that all pans out by showing how the government/state/prison/DAs wanted to grind Woodfox down to stop appealing for justice.

Woodfox is really paying back to reading, what reading did for him:

Reading was a bright spot for me. Reading was my salvation. Libraries and universities and schools from all over Louisiana donated books to Angola and for once, the willful ignorance of the prison administration paid off for us, because there were a lot of radical books in the prison library: Books we wouldn’t have been allowed to get through the mail. Books we never could have afforded to buy. Books we had never heard of. Herman, King, and I first gravitated to books and authors that dealt with politics and race—George Jackson, Frantz Fanon, Malcolm X, Marcus Garvey, Steve Biko, Eldridge Cleaver’s Soul on Ice, J. A. Rogers’s From ‘Superman’ to Man. We read anything we could find on slavery, communism, socialism, Marxism, anti-imperialism, the African independence movements, and independence movements from around the world.

There's so much good in this book. I hope it gets spread everywhere.

“Prison is designed to break one’s spirit and destroy one’s resolve. To do this, the authorities attempt to exploit every weakness, demolish every initiative, negate all signs of individuality—all with the idea of stamping out that spark that makes each of us human and each of us who we are. Our survival depended on understanding what the authorities were attempting to do to us, and sharing that understanding with each other. —Nelson Mandela”

“If any white man in the world says ‘Give me liberty, or give me death,’ the entire world applauds. When a black man says exactly the same thing, word for word, he is judged a criminal and treated like one.”
—James Baldwin

“When you see organizations like Black Lives Matter under attack for being “racist,” you are seeing the agenda of an unjust economic system at play—a system that seeks to separate groups of people within the majority to benefit the top 1 percent.”

Albert Woodfox was released from prison in February 2016. He was in his mid-60s. He spent over 40 years in solitary confinement, trapped in a 9 by 6 cell, for a crime he did not commit. This was in the notorious Angola prison, in Louisiana. This is Albert's story and it is heart-breaking, rage-inducing and in the end triumphant. Instead of becoming a broken man, he became a strong advocate for prison reform, which he continues to do, as he travels the world speaking out. This memoir reminded me of The Autobiography of Malcolm X, in many ways. It is that powerful, articulate and focused. Our prison system is destroying many lives and needs a complete overhaul. I hope, one day, our leaders will correct this American travesty.½

I rank it alongside "No Friend But the Mountains: Writing from Manus Prison" as a commentary on the corruptible nature of power. The carelessness with which political powers, bureaucratic systems, profit-making enterprises and racist belief inflict egregious and enduring violence beggars belief. The profound lack of humanity spills off every page of this thick book. The book's very endlessness evokes the unrelenting nature of the violence endured by so many in the Louisiana prison system. And, lest we think the American South is an exception, also the hope-destroying violence of Manus Prison and Australia's treatment of boat people and others in detention.