The idea was stronger than the execution. ( )

Maybe one star is one too many. ( )

Alien warriors crash land in the old west.

1.5/4 (Meh).

My understanding is this book exists purely as a means to sell a pitch for an action movie. It is the quality you would expect from that. ( )

A fun romp of a comic! The title says it all, well, except Native Americans are in the fight too! It's a fast paced story, maybe even too fast paced! But it's a fun one! ( )

Wow, this was a total let down. I wanted to read the graphic novel before I saw the movie, but now all I can think is the movie has to be better. The concept is great, but the story and illustrations were ridiculous (not even in a funny way). I knew it was going to be bad when the American Indians had these huge six-pack abs and names like "No Name." I can't believe this is classified as adult and not juvenile. The best thing about this graphic novel is the cover. Skip it. ( )