As an adult reading this book I found myself saying "no, don't do it, it's a trap" to Aria quite a lot while she was trying to complete the quest. I think that kids will enjoy this book and will have a harder time seeing the trap that Aria is being led in to. I love that by the end of the book all the the otherlings have the same knowledge and I hope that the elements start sharing more information with them so things like this don't happen in the future. Overall, a fun, middle grade read. ( )